Re: RD 12 | Hull FC v Leeds Rhinos : Fri Apr 20, 2018 12:26 pm  

Another close game we bombed. Poor discipline & lack of cohesion proving costly again.

[Karen]

Re: RD 12 | Hull FC v Leeds Rhinos : Fri Apr 20, 2018 12:28 pm  

chapylad wrote:

Or was it deemed Parcell didn't score hence just the penalty try?

Parcell knocked on therefore it was a penalty try rather than an 8 point try

Re: RD 12 | Hull FC v Leeds Rhinos : Fri Apr 20, 2018 12:36 pm  

I think Thaler gave you a fair few penalties to even out the ones he didnt give for you in the Wigan game.

Re: RD 12 | Hull FC v Leeds Rhinos : Fri Apr 20, 2018 1:43 pm  

chapylad wrote:

Thought we were way off last night and only played for 20 minutes or so.
How Moon was in the top 4 by the so called Rugby legends is another mystery.
He needs to move back to centre and we either need Lilley in the halves or we need to find a half asap.
Who was the guy the commentators were on about from Australia who could be moving to SL?
Is he a half and more importantly is he any good?
If Moon is there for his pivotal play and tackling then Lilley could match that.
The forwards were ok but needed some size to make a difference.
Hull played reasonably well and for me Kelly was the difference .
Kelly in a Leeds shirt and we would have won that game.
Hull deserved the win last night but I would be a tad worried if a one point win against a below strength and below performing team is considered "a good win"
On the other hand you can only play what is in front of you and Hull did that and got the 2 points.
The worry is if Cuthbertson and possibly Ward are injured on top of what we have out it could be a long few weeks ahead.
What happened to the 8 point try for a foul in the art of scoring?
Or was it deemed Parcell didn't score hence just the penalty try?

Ward tweeted lastnight that he is OK and 'fit foor next week if picked'

Re: RD 12 | Hull FC v Leeds Rhinos : Fri Apr 20, 2018 1:55 pm  

Neruda wrote:

seemed like a cop out to me - otherwise, wouldnt every team just try and kick the ball out of a players possession when theyre in the act of scoring? what exactly was the penalty against them, a try we were scoring anyway? you're losing nothing by doing it. should have penalised the dangerous play and given us a pen under the sticks, or sin binned their player imo

should have called game over and awarded you the 2 points

Re: RD 12 | Hull FC v Leeds Rhinos : Fri Apr 20, 2018 2:14 pm  

Karen wrote:

I have never seen a player get sin binned following a penalty try being awarded whilst the team is on a team warning, do you have an example?

Give me an example where the team is on a warning and didn’t happen.

I repeat, it is bad interpretation by officials which are wrong, because like you said, when not on a warning it isn’t sinbinned.

[Karen]

Re: RD 12 | Hull FC v Leeds Rhinos : Fri Apr 20, 2018 2:22 pm  

Gotcha wrote:

Give me an example where the team is on a warning and didn’t happen.

I repeat, it is bad interpretation by officials which are wrong, because like you said, when not on a warning it isn’t sinbinned.

Still doesn't alter the fact that you cannot penalise a team for the same offence twice!

Re: RD 12 | Hull FC v Leeds Rhinos : Fri Apr 20, 2018 2:24 pm  

Backwoodsman wrote:

Can’t complain about the result, not much between both teams but hull just about deserved it. We probably used up too much energy in the first half. Golding was rock solid at full back, handley looked a bit frail. Hall justified his world class wingers tag.
Probably singleton would have made a difference last night. Unfortunately our atacking plays seemed very slow and predictable . At the moment saints and Wigan seem to be the best teams, obviously that can change. On the plus side hull managed to field the strongest team available and just scraped a win. We however are still well down on numbers. Tonight’s match at Wigan may indicate how cas are progressing.

Hall justified his world class wingers tag. does hall ever need to justify anything, along with big les the best winger of the super league era by some margin. awesome try last night a combination of though sheer power and a bit guile, and i would rather see a player score like that than flying over the corner flag, any winger can score when its handed on the plate.

Re: RD 12 | Hull FC v Leeds Rhinos : Fri Apr 20, 2018 2:41 pm  

rollin thunder wrote:

Hall justified his world class wingers tag. does hall ever need to justify anything, along with big les the best winger of the super league era by some margin. awesome try last night a combination of though sheer power and a bit guile, and i would rather see a player score like that than flying over the corner flag, any winger can score when its handed on the plate.

Fans of other teams on these boards every year for the last few now wanting him put out to pasture for england at the expense of the latest jonny come lately that has bagged 30 odd walk in tries for their team.still the best winger in england and SL for me and has been for almost a decade now.Leeds and England will be far worse off when he does move on.

Re: RD 12 | Hull FC v Leeds Rhinos : Fri Apr 20, 2018 2:45 pm  

rollin thunder wrote:

Hall justified his world class wingers tag. does hall ever need to justify anything, along with big les the best winger of the super league era by some margin. awesome try last night a combination of though sheer power and a bit guile, and i would rather see a player score like that than flying over the corner flag, any winger can score when its handed on the plate.

Got sold 2 dummies by Jake connor though