Re: who can we beat in the middle 8s : Tue Jul 25, 2017 1:19 pm  

When i said top 5 i did mean it in your suggested format,there should be a million pound match however many go up.

Re: who can we beat in the middle 8s : Tue Jul 25, 2017 1:54 pm  

mr t hall wrote:

Where does this myth come from ? This season has never been about who tops the league in the first part of the season.IF super league runs with 13 next year then the top 5 of qualifiers should go up and if HKR don't make that they stay down..simple..

It comes from the press who reported that at the meeting of SL clubs a few weeks ago when the 13 team SL was floated that HKR would be the 13th team if they failed to get back through the current 8's and million pound game.
As stated in the post on the 13th team MK confirms it was put forward and would be funded by taking money from the Championship so the idea is definitely more than a myth.
HKR are the team chosen because of the numbers of their supporters that have been lost to the other SL clubs
home games and the money involved.
Other relevant press statements have said any changes would would not affect this years comps.
They probably think it likely that what happened to HKR will not happen again this year certainly not by Fax, Fev or London.
If HKR were to win the million pound game against say Catalans then HKR would go up and it would be Cats that got to stay up to make up the 13.
It's impossible for anyone to know how things will work out at this time not even the clubs know, certainly not the Championship clubs because at their recent meeting it was reported virtually nothing of any substance was discussed.
My question to anyone is how they would feel if their club got this sort of shoein regardless of on field performance.
It would be the most clear unprecedented preferential treatment in the history of rugby league.
Would they not give a dam as long as they benefitted or would they see the harm this would cause.
Not that it will ever happen to Fax but if it did I would not want any part of it.

Re: who can we beat in the middle 8s : Tue Jul 25, 2017 2:08 pm  

Only rugby league could consider a possibility that if you don't go up we'll change the format and promote you anyway...would be a fecking disgrace.Hope Red Hall have the resolve to stand up to the greedy,selfish,shortsighted +++++ like Wigan.

Re: who can we beat in the middle 8s : Tue Jul 25, 2017 2:26 pm  

mr t hall wrote:

Only rugby league could consider a possibility that if you don't go up we'll change the format and promote you anyway...would be a fecking disgrace.Hope Red Hall have the resolve to stand up to the greedy,selfish,shortsighted +++++ like Wigan.

Absolutely.
Only clubs who deserve to be there on merit should be there.
Leigh did it the right way after a lot of hard earned cash and a number of years preparation.
I just can't believe how any person in a responsible position could even be thinking down these lines.
Do they not see the impact on the clubs, coaches and playing staffs lives this would have, are we supporters who can be just written off as nothing.

Re: who can we beat in the middle 8s : Tue Jul 25, 2017 5:53 pm  

the fax in asia wrote:

Was it not Moxi bragging at the start of the season about going unbeaten, I thought he was going to put his house on that, or was it his shirt ?

No, you've confused me with someone else there.

Re: who can we beat in the middle 8s : Tue Jul 25, 2017 5:57 pm  

faxcar wrote:

Well we could pull off an upset but I agree HKR should be too strong for us at home and rightly so comparing the differences in budgets and between a full and part time team.

You will of course need all the first choice players being match fit and with some just returning from injury that's not possible.

The question will be for the Robins can HKR avoid any banana skins when playing the other Championship clubs and then get past the SL teams, would you still put your house on it.
The longer you stay in the Championship the harder it is to get out and on that point.

Could I ask how you would feel about the alleged proposal to get HKR back into SL regardless of on field performances by forming the 13 team comp and funding it by taking the money from the Championship clubs to do so.

I'd expect and hope we go up on our own merit, as for funding, rovers don't really struggle to fund themselves like others. I'm not saying we can fund ourselves to max cap but we get good crowds, merchandise sales and lots of events held at craven park that make the club a lot of money and allows us to spend more then others on the available cap. So to answer your question on the funding, can't really say I have an opinion either way.

Re: who can we beat in the middle 8s : Tue Jul 25, 2017 6:38 pm  

moxi1 wrote:

I'd expect and hope we go up on our own merit, as for funding, rovers don't really struggle to fund themselves like others. I'm not saying we can fund ourselves to max cap but we get good crowds, merchandise sales and lots of events held at craven park that make the club a lot of money and allows us to spend more then others on the available cap. So to answer your question on the funding, can't really say I have an opinion either way.

Fax were in a similar position when were relegated from SL all them years ago with good support etc.
Promotion and relegation was scrapped and we were cut adrift, we stayed down and slowly but surely the crowds went down the sponsering went down.
That's one of the reasons SL knows if HKR are to return it has to be soon, a couple of years go by and it could be too late.
SL has taken a hit with crowds over the last couple of years with losing Bradford.
Now HKR and your supporters who travel away not to mention the 2 Hull derbys and the Magic Weekend match.
Not good for the game if the game is just SL.
You can see why they want you back and all they have to do is alter the structure and if the minor clubs who in Lenagans stated comments will never be good enough pick up the tab who cares.
Nothing to do with you mate but you can see why the rest of us feel less than impressed.

Re: who can we beat in the middle 8s : Tue Jul 25, 2017 6:48 pm  

I think as long as we give a good account for ourselves in the 8's we can't really complain. In 2015 we won 2 and lost 5, finishing 6th. Leigh, who walked the Championship rounds won 1 and lost 7... Maybe it could happen to KR this time round? Who knows, but its exciting times!

Re: who can we beat in the middle 8s : Tue Jul 25, 2017 10:26 pm  

I know it is going to be hard for us come on we will be playing 6 full time teams and we have never beaten a SL club since we came down to the Championship, my hope is that we beat Fev finally at home and put that hoodoo to bed plus we catch either Catalans or Widnes on an off day, it would be good to have a decent start in the Qualifiers and not have our toughest games up front.
My hope is that we win at least 2 games but you never know with the togetherness of the team we may surprise a few teams and there is no pressure on us but lots on the rest maybe Fev apart, hopefully we won't do like Fev last year and lose all 7 games.

Re: who can we beat in the middle 8s : Wed Jul 26, 2017 4:19 am  

Quote
Re: hukll kr away
Post Fri Mar 24, 2017 12:21 am
moxi1
User avatar
Bronze RLFANS Member
Bronze RLFANS Member

Joined: Sat Jul 08, 2006 4:38 am
Posts: 3489

I'm not saying we'll go up, but I do believe we'll top the regular season without getting out of second gear. Sadly, the season starts come the 8s.


Apologies Moxi it wasn't your shirt or your house, you obviously stayed in first gear last sunday!


Come on the Fax

.