: Sat May 09, 2009 11:13 pm  

griffax wrote:

Also, Lee missed a conversion from out wide, would have won us the game with his kicking otherwise

It's a waste of time going on about if's and buts we could go on all night
Cas scored 7 tries to Fax's 5 if all our convertions had gone over Cas would have still won
So let's just say it was a great game and your luck ran out at the end

keep the Faith

: Sat May 09, 2009 11:17 pm  

golden point is crap. team that kicks off loses. might as well just settle it with the coin toss

: Sat May 09, 2009 11:18 pm  

Doncaster Tiger wrote:

It's a waste of time going on about if's and buts we could go on all night
Cas scored 7 tries to Fax's 5 if all our convertions had gone over Cas would have still won
So let's just say it was a great game and your luck ran out at the end

keep the Faith

Erm, I wouldn't say OUR luck ran out at the end, I'd say you got lucky at the end!

: Sat May 09, 2009 11:48 pm  

freddies wig wrote:

golden point is crap. team that kicks off loses. might as well just settle it with the coin toss

not been funny, but would you have said that if we won??

: Sat May 09, 2009 11:57 pm  

Actually, yeah. I appreciate that matches have to be settled but to turn a well fought out, even competition into a lottery seems a bit cheap. extra time yes but golden point where in theory only one team should get to play, no. We'd probably have lost with extra time but it would have felt a bit fairer.

: Sun May 10, 2009 7:09 am  

freddies wig wrote:

golden point is crap. team that kicks off loses. might as well just settle it with the coin toss

i cant go with that,you make it sound like popping a drop goal over from 40 metres out is easy.

i also want to say that i thought your team were fantastic and had great support from the fans,it was a game like no other ive seen although the defences left a lot to be desired lets just say both attacks were in good form.i think golden point was the right way to go you only after go back to last years nl grand final where one team gets a role on like saford did and it takes the shine off what was a fantastic game.

: Sun May 10, 2009 7:12 am  

braytontiger wrote:

i cant go with that,you make it sound like popping a drop goal over from 40 metres out is easy.

i also want to say that i thought your team were fantastic and had great support from the fans,it was a game like no other ive seen although the defences left a lot to be desired lets just say both attacks were in good form.i think golden point was the right way to go you only after go back to last years nl grand final where one team gets a role on like saford did and it takes the shine off what was a fantastic game.

A full time SL Side should have no problem scoring 30-40 points against lower league opposition, but to concede the same...

Most we've scored against a SL side for a while. And I dont think manyu other Championship clubs will manage a tally as high in the remaining games in this round.

: Sun May 10, 2009 9:13 am  

Doncaster Tiger wrote:

It's a waste of time going on about if's and buts we could go on all night Cas scored 7 tries to Fax's 5 if all our convertions had gone over Cas would have still won
So let's just say it was a great game and your luck ran out at the end

keep the Faith

Thats what these boards are here for though to discuss the game. We cold talk about it all night and all day, nobodies asking you to join in.

: Sun May 10, 2009 9:21 am  

Golden point IMO should only come into play after extra time has been played. Is a gutting way to lose.