Re: Play offs : Sun Sep 25, 2022 9:13 pm  

Ohmetoe wrote:

Brilliant by batley showing us the way forward yet again . Manning was one we should have never released the guy just tackled for ever .

Agree on the Batley performance but it's how they have played for most of the season so no real shock in the result.
Agree also about Manning being a top Championship player throughout his career.
However you are incorrect in stating that we released him, Fax wanted him to stay.
Manning left when the club asked all the playing staff at that time to take a pay cut, he refused and went to Batley.

Re: Play offs : Sun Sep 25, 2022 10:54 pm  

Brilliant by Batley. Great club. I’m delighted for them (also cos they beat Fev too…)

But. Now the final two are decided, serious thought needs to be put into the sport. Will Batley take their place in super league if, by some miracle, they beat Leigh? With the greatest respect to Batley, super league would be the death of the club (and every other club in the championship..). Serious thought needs to be put into the future of the sport, the disparity between super league and championship is staggering. The very existence of a club shouldn’t be threatened by being successful and getting promoted. Some hard work ahead for the RFL and IGM.

Re: Play offs : Mon Sep 26, 2022 7:47 am  

freddies wig wrote:

Brilliant by Batley. Great club. I’m delighted for them (also cos they beat Fev too…)

But. Now the final two are decided, serious thought needs to be put into the sport. Will Batley take their place in super league if, by some miracle, they beat Leigh? With the greatest respect to Batley, super league would be the death of the club (and every other club in the championship..). Serious thought needs to be put into the future of the sport, the disparity between super league and championship is staggering. The very existence of a club shouldn’t be threatened by being successful and getting promoted. Some hard work ahead for the RFL and IGM.

That's a good post and very thought provoking.

Re: Play offs : Mon Sep 26, 2022 8:33 am  

I think leigh will determine the answer , they are just too strong for batley and will rightly in my view be promoted again . Also agree I dont think it would be good for batley to be in SL . The infrastructure or the stadium just isnt there. They are an extremely well run and managed championship club fullstop

Re: Play offs : Mon Sep 26, 2022 8:50 am  

freddies wig wrote:

Brilliant by Batley. Great club. I’m delighted for them (also cos they beat Fev too…)

But. Now the final two are decided, serious thought needs to be put into the sport. Will Batley take their place in super league if, by some miracle, they beat Leigh? With the greatest respect to Batley, super league would be the death of the club (and every other club in the championship..). Serious thought needs to be put into the future of the sport, the disparity between super league and championship is staggering. The very existence of a club shouldn’t be threatened by being successful and getting promoted. Some hard work ahead for the RFL and IGM.

On the same question and a bit closer to home SG was asked that by the tv pundits after the win at Widnes.

Are Fax ready for Super League? His reply, "absolutely not" but would be take it "absolutely yes".

In part he did mention that the infra structure wasn't in place at the moment, the funding required, uncertainties on the proposed changes to the league structure and that maybe going full time would be one of the steps for us to aim for would be in the right direction.

For us the best I can see is a few changes in the playing staff with hopefully 2 or 3 quality players coming in to lift the level of play.

Same old problem, even with a big financial backer nothing is guaranteed but without one it's hard to see any club not only being able to get there but sustaining it afterwards.

Re: Play offs : Mon Sep 26, 2022 9:18 am  

freddies wig wrote:

Brilliant by Batley. Great club. I’m delighted for them (also cos they beat Fev too…)

But. Now the final two are decided, serious thought needs to be put into the sport. Will Batley take their place in super league if, by some miracle, they beat Leigh? With the greatest respect to Batley, super league would be the death of the club (and every other club in the championship..). Serious thought needs to be put into the future of the sport, the disparity between super league and championship is staggering. The very existence of a club shouldn’t be threatened by being successful and getting promoted. Some hard work ahead for the RFL and IGM.

Spot on what sort of sport are we supporting when getting promoted to the top league of the sport can mean the down fall of that club.