: Sat Jun 06, 2009 10:04 pm  

Uptoncat wrote:

to be honest Thaler didn't have a bad game, watch it when you've all calmed down and you'll see he wasn't bad at all.

Thanks for that, Mrs Thaler.

: Sat Jun 06, 2009 10:08 pm  

Poker Face wrote:

What's the point in complaining about refereeing decisions ?

It's done. Game over. We lost.

found it quite funny how evans holds his hands in air appealing to ref after tackles when at acting halfback. seems to do it every time. sure he did it one time well before the tackle was even completed.
he must be taking a leaf out of footballers manual of appeals.

: Sat Jun 06, 2009 10:12 pm  

swifty62 wrote:

found it quite funny how evans holds his hands in air appealing to ref after tackles when at acting halfback. seems to do it every time. sure he did it one time well before the tackle was even completed.
he must be taking a leaf out of footballers manual of appeals.

Swings and roundabouts. Nobody complained when the Wire player dropped the ball and threw his hands in he air for a (given) penalty.

: Sat Jun 06, 2009 11:01 pm  

pyeman wrote:

Are you honestly telling me that you didnt see alot of mistakes in wires favour? at least one try was a forward pass that was missed and some of the calls that went wires way were ridiculous, a warrington player puts his hand up to palm down a kick it goes 10 yards forwards and its not a knock on?

watch it again you`ll see those decisions were correct....again the better team won deal with it

: Sat Jun 06, 2009 11:57 pm  

Gaslight wrote:

Or how about Morley tripping Chase up? or Rauhihi elbowing Westerman in the face? they never happened either apparently

Did he really? You shouldn't believe everything you hear, especially when it comes out of Eddie Hemmings mouth.

: Sun Jun 07, 2009 1:07 am  

Goldy as passionate as he is needs to keep his gob shout abusing officials..swearing at them? It aint captain material. Im 1 of Goldys biggest fans...but seriously Grit your teeth.. challenge the ref in the correct manner, go to your team mates and discuss the decision and lead by example in the next part of play. Im not saying it cost us the game.. but if our captain is getting sin binned what leadership is out there?

: Sun Jun 07, 2009 10:12 am  

BigNige wrote:

Mistake 1. When Netherton was subbed Chase moved to hooker & the shuffle around of personnel as a consequence cost us a try.

Mistake 2. Matterson using Chase in two key roles. The jobs hard enough as it is without taking away our Scrum Half (stand in) & having no back up therefore no control in the centre of the park.

Mistake 3. I know he's a fans favorite etc. (not in this house) but the day that McGoldrick is back on the boat to Oz can't come too soon for me. He's a liability, must give 2 interception per match, letting the ball bounce, not securing the ball in hand (again must be at least twice per game where he looses it in the tackle), lack of self discipline, I know he's captain at the mo so can ask the ref questions but he goes too far & got 10 minutes for it (Thaler was sh*te but that's no excuse).

i would agree with all that mate, that is spot on. chase should be left alone to do his own job. fantastic player. big future. too big for matterson. mcgoldrick is his own worst enemy. just when cas is under the cosh and needs a captain to steady the ship, he spits his dummy out and lets everybody down. as for thaler , i think he had a good game, went to the video for any thing contentious. can't see as he did much wrong.

: Sun Jun 07, 2009 11:08 am  

pyeman wrote:

Are you honestly telling me that you didnt see alot of mistakes in wires favour? at least one try was a forward pass that was missed and some of the calls that went wires way were ridiculous, a warrington player puts his hand up to palm down a kick it goes 10 yards forwards and its not a knock on?

As to the last point, it's called a 'charge down' and is perfectly legal - play on. Refs make mistakes in all games - God knows we've had plenty this year - so you have to play on regardless. Wire were the better team overall, apart from the first twenty minutes, and deserved to win.

: Sun Jun 07, 2009 12:01 pm  

also less than 6200 there thought you lot had more fans than that

: Sun Jun 07, 2009 12:13 pm  

Les Boyd Is God wrote:

also less than 6200 there thought you lot had more fans than that

Other things were possibly going on.