But as a player only is a no-brainer. He's probably better than any of our current backrowers. This thread would be very dull on that basis.
I don't dismiss cheating that easily, and can fully understand why some don't want him at the club, and also the fact that its more than likely that he or Huby has to leave Hudds (BTW not only has this happened but its also been publicised to the world, which must make it worse).
Having said that I'd go with what senior players think.