Re: CCRD 6 | Leeds Rhinos v Barrow Raiders : Sun May 14, 2017 4:53 pm  

Gotcha wrote:

What a waste of an opportunity that. What can we learn from that. Perfect opportunity for youngsters game time massively missed.

To be fair, Barrow are CC1 and the dual reg lads are getting better experience than this week on week anyway playing in the Championship. Would it impress you to see them tearing up Barrow at home anyway, it wouldn't mean they could hack SL just because they were doing it in a Leeds shirt would it?

Re: CCRD 6 | Leeds Rhinos v Barrow Raiders : Sun May 14, 2017 4:59 pm  

Magsy ,Burrow and JJB will be thinking about maybe one last trophy

Re: CCRD 6 | Leeds Rhinos v Barrow Raiders : Sun May 14, 2017 5:03 pm  

Clearwing wrote:

Can't imagine it'd achieve much unless they were going to get more games imminently. How long would the experience stay with the youngsters and how long would their performances remain in the minds of the coaches? To my mind better to rehearse a few moves and improve cohesion between some of the players that will have important roles to play.

In a couple of weeks the coach will be moaning about too many games in a short period. To add to that we have another cup round that a lot of other super league sides don't have and have week off. To add to that, we at supposedly in transition, and about to seperate from further established players for next season. Surely you need players ready, if not fully physically, definitely mentally? We had an opportunity to aid the medium to long term so much. That score line today was always going to happen, it was a division one team.

Re: CCRD 6 | Leeds Rhinos v Barrow Raiders : Sun May 14, 2017 5:05 pm  

Biff Tannen wrote:

To be fair, Barrow are CC1 and the dual reg lads are getting better experience than this week on week anyway playing in the Championship. Would it impress you to see them tearing up Barrow at home anyway, it wouldn't mean they could hack SL just because they were doing it in a Leeds shirt would it?

Surely the mental preparation for a cup tie is far greater? A much better experience to learn. So yes, I would have rather seen how they react to the pressure, than a training session for established players.

Re: CCRD 6 | Leeds Rhinos v Barrow Raiders : Sun May 14, 2017 5:09 pm  

Personally think hes made the right call, cas are obviously the best side in the comp at the minute and getting some cohesion going into that game is their best opportunity to get a performance that would raise and consolidate some confidence. Whos to say how they will perform but if they came up with a Huddersfield type performance on the back of resting players the doncaster experience would no doubt be highlighted.

Re: CCRD 6 | Leeds Rhinos v Barrow Raiders : Sun May 14, 2017 5:20 pm  

I can see both sides. however I think the older players.
, if only a couple, should have been given a rest

Re: CCRD 6 | Leeds Rhinos v Barrow Raiders : Sun May 14, 2017 5:28 pm  

The only ones i could really think of giving a rest would be JJB and maybe hall, not your pivots for obvious reasons and golding is young anyway and missed a few. from the forwards galloways already missed loads, ferres just coming back, certainly not ward or singleton. Also liam Sutcliffe needs time in the centres as it looks like thatll be his role this season and the next in line in the case of injuries is handley so he no doubt benefitted.

Re: CCRD 6 | Leeds Rhinos v Barrow Raiders : Sun May 14, 2017 5:30 pm  

Gotcha wrote:

Surely the mental preparation for a cup tie is far greater? A much better experience to learn. So yes, I would have rather seen how they react to the pressure, than a training session for established players.

I do see your point but i don't think it's something to get hung up about.

i would much rather see these fringe lads get game time against weaker SL teams when the chance presents itself though to see if they can hack it than virtual walkovers like this today.

Re: CCRD 6 | Leeds Rhinos v Barrow Raiders : Sun May 14, 2017 6:11 pm  

Some fair points above, but Mac spelled out his decisions last week. Better the fringe players get some guaranteed game time than waiting for injuries that would get them first team action. We need some game time with the best players available to take on a Castleford side that are the best team in the competition at the moment. Looks like we've come through unscathed. All in all, looking as good as it could.

Re: CCRD 6 | Leeds Rhinos v Barrow Raiders : Sun May 14, 2017 6:15 pm  

All will be forgiven when we hand em their sorry black n amber a$$es on a plate.