: Fri Sep 28, 2007 9:34 am  

Damo-Leeds wrote:

Tomorrow I just can’t see a Saints win for a number of reasons. One of the reasons is their over rated full back who got in this years dream team in favour of Brent Webb who is obviously better than the pair. Brent Webb has a point to prove tomorrow and I feel that he’ll do it well.

We then have the declining star in Sean Long who I am glad is back tomorrow. It keeps that Mattie Smith out of the game and that's make me happy that Leeds don’t have to face another young spark like James Roby.

If Leeds had a choice to have Nick Fozzard or Kylie I think there made their decision ages ago. Fozzard is a good prop but he is only in that dream team because of the commentaries love of St Helens and their unsung players.

Leeds just have a better team all round and I can’t see St Helens beating us for years unless the rumours are true. Jamie Lyon is coming back to St Helens? I very doubt it. He has a point to prove down under and I think he will next season.

I say bring on the battle!

And the lesson to be learnt from this post is..............Stay off the drugs before using the internet.

: Fri Sep 28, 2007 9:38 am  

fanstanningley wrote:

Can't remember Ablett dropping a clanger but certainly remember loads from Thackary.

Cant remember Ablett changing games very often but certainly remember Thackray doing so!

For all Thackrays faults he certainly brings far more to the squad than Carl Ablett ever has or ever will.

: Fri Sep 28, 2007 9:41 am  

darwoo11 wrote:

Cant remember Ablett changing very often games but certainly remember Thackray doing so!

For all Thackrays faults he certainly brings far more to the squad than Carl Ablett ever has or ever will.

So Ablett isn't as likely to drop a clanger then?

I remember seeing a few line breaks from Ablett recently. That's something he could bring isn't it?

: Fri Sep 28, 2007 9:49 am  

El Diablo wrote:

So Ablett isn't as likely to drop a clanger then?

I remember seeing a few line breaks from Ablett recently. That's something he could bring isn't it?

add to that his good hands, his quick feet, his good defence, the big hits, the reliability, the versatility

then again, not like any of them matter in rugby :rolleyes:

: Fri Sep 28, 2007 9:52 am  

I simply believe Thackray brings a lot more to the game than Ablett has, Ablett is workmanlike but in fairness often drops off tackles.

It isn't that I think Ablett doesn't have plus points, its that I personally would choose Thackray over him every time.

: Fri Sep 28, 2007 9:54 am  

darwoo11 wrote:

Cant remember Ablett changing games very often but certainly remember Thackray doing so!

For all Thackrays faults he certainly brings far more to the squad than Carl Ablett ever has or ever will.

Did is break not change the game against Hull KR at Headingley?

The argument should not be Thackray or Ablett but Thackray or Bailey?

: Fri Sep 28, 2007 10:11 am  

Eccleshill Rhino wrote:

Did is break not change the game against Hull KR at Headingley?

The argument should not be Thackray or Ablett but Thackray or Bailey?

I'd say Thackray or Kirke myself.

Personally I would have gone with Jamie. Yes he makes mistakes but he offers more in attack than Kirke, who despite being eager appears limited.

: Fri Sep 28, 2007 10:15 am  

doesn't make a lot of errors kirke. limited ability but pretty error free

: Fri Sep 28, 2007 10:18 am  

Lord_Percy wrote:

I'd say Thackray or Kirke myself.

Personally I would have gone with Jamie. Yes he makes mistakes but he offers more in attack than Kirke, who despite being eager appears limited.

Nah, i'd go with Kirke, far more reliable.

: Fri Sep 28, 2007 10:18 am  

I expect (and hope) that tonight will really see the kind of intensity you only get from finals rugby, and in that case the error count could be really crucial. That's likely to be in TS' thinking. 2 or 3 dropped balls in your own territory could cost you the game in this kind of match.