Page 3 of 8

Re: Lack of talent recruit from union

PostPosted: Mon Jan 02, 2017 9:08 pm
by William Eve
ThePrinter wrote:
Nope you've just been repeating the same lines over and over on here that it's impossible to forget what they are.

Just answer the question, how long is this decade before semi pro going to last??? You were saying it when I first started posting on here in 2011 so surely you only have a few years left?

So it's half a decade now? 8)

Re: General Topic | Lack of talent recruit from union

PostPosted: Mon Jan 02, 2017 9:16 pm
by Chesterrhino
Bill is correct super league ain't super any more how can it be when it can't even support an a team league bring that back to begin with and the kids will stay in the game longer players stay at clubs for longer also should allow a teasers to remain semi pro.

Re: General Topic | Lack of talent recruit from union

PostPosted: Mon Jan 02, 2017 9:20 pm
by William Eve
The really interesting question would be...

Could Leeds realistically remain full time pro without the annual foodbank handout from Sky?

Re: General Topic | Lack of talent recruit from union

PostPosted: Mon Jan 02, 2017 9:34 pm
by DHM
Cap in English union is 7 million and it will go up. I don't think they have a cap in France. Wasps made an operating loss of 3.8 million end of last season, they can't exist without input from owners, but that's not the point. The point is that RU players are not interested in league. There's no money in it, and no good reason to switch.

Facts are facts. Quins can fill Twickenham for a league fixture and a resurgent England have massively revitalised the international game as a whole. The profile, the money, the safety and security in the mini and junior game, player development pathways, European club competition etc. Union didn't just go professional, it got it's act together in a big way at all levels.

It may be unsustainable, but Union is I think on the brink of really taking off. Japan World Cup could kick it off to a genuinely global audience. It could go big or it could pop like an over inflated balloon. Whatever, there's no "talent" for league clubs to poach anymore.

Re: Lack of talent recruit from union

PostPosted: Mon Jan 02, 2017 9:43 pm
by ThePrinter
William Eve wrote:
So it's half a decade now? 8)


"the game will be semi pro in a decades time" - William Eve - January 2029

Re: General Topic | Lack of talent recruit from union

PostPosted: Mon Jan 02, 2017 9:45 pm
by Chestnutrhino
Just a quick one on the view about getting Union players early in their careers.There is a lad that has just played his 100th game for Carnegie,as a youngster played league to service area standard,could play FB or SO very good defence and great under high ball got overlooked by rhinos acadamey but I know is a big league fan and considers his grounding in the game contributed a lot to his success in Union.

Re: General Topic | Lack of talent recruit from union

PostPosted: Mon Jan 02, 2017 10:14 pm
by William Eve
DHM wrote:
Cap in English union is 7 million and it will go up. I don't think they have a cap in France. Wasps made an operating loss of 3.8 million end of last season, they can't exist without input from owners, but that's not the point. The point is that RU players are not interested in league. There's no money in it, and no good reason to switch.

Facts are facts. Quins can fill Twickenham for a league fixture and a resurgent England have massively revitalised the international game as a whole. The profile, the money, the safety and security in the mini and junior game, player development pathways, European club competition etc. Union didn't just go professional, it got it's act together in a big way at all levels.

It may be unsustainable, but Union is I think on the brink of really taking off. Japan World Cup could kick it off to a genuinely global audience. It could go big or it could pop like an over inflated balloon. Whatever, there's no "talent" for league clubs to poach anymore.

Agreed.

Union has got it's @rse in gear since it became full time pro.

I wasn't convinced that club rugby in Union would take off but it has done.

The benefits of a thriving, touring international stage is a huge help of course, along with good management.

In comparison, RL has allowed its own much smaller international touring stage to become an afterthought and something that gets in the way.

Re: General Topic | Lack of talent recruit from union

PostPosted: Mon Jan 02, 2017 10:33 pm
by DHM
William Eve wrote:
Agreed.

Union has got it's @rse in gear since it became full time pro.

I wasn't convinced that club rugby in Union would take off but it has done.

The benefits of a thriving, touring international stage is a huge help of course, along with good management.

In comparison, RL has allowed its own much smaller international touring stage to become an afterthought and something that gets in the way.


Can you imagine league clubs releasing all their top players for 9 weekends during the season to play internationals?
GB could fit in a full tour of Australia if they did.

Re: General Topic | Lack of talent recruit from union

PostPosted: Mon Jan 02, 2017 10:43 pm
by Sal Paradise
William Eve wrote:
Agreed.

Union has got it's @rse in gear since it became full time pro.

I wasn't convinced that club rugby in Union would take off but it has done.

The benefits of a thriving, touring international stage is a huge help of course, along with good management.

In comparison, RL has allowed its own much smaller international touring stage to become an afterthought and something that gets in the way.


The international game in RL has always been very small by comparison. Like cricket the international game underpins the whole sport. The biggest team in RU is the All Blacks so its no wonder the clubs release their players for international duty

Re: General Topic | Lack of talent recruit from union

PostPosted: Mon Jan 02, 2017 10:46 pm
by William Eve
DHM wrote:
Can you imagine league clubs releasing all their top players for 9 weekends during the season to play internationals?
GB could fit in a full tour of Australia if they did.

Not a chance of that happening in RL.

They won't even allow players to be released during the off-season as it'll get in the way of their pre-season schedule of public training runs.

Isn't there a British Lions Tour of NZ during the UK summer off-season of 2017?

Good luck to SL getting any media coverage while that Tour is taking place.