Re: OUT MS 2019 | Matt Parcell - Hull Kingston Rovers : Fri Jun 28, 2019 10:40 am  

Walker has had a couple of shockers this year (the first Wigan game comes to mind).
In an ideal world, he comes into a solid and high quality side which can support him better while he learns.
Big fan of his as a player, has some x-factor which is rare in this side.

Re: OUT MS 2019 | Matt Parcell - Hull Kingston Rovers : Fri Jun 28, 2019 10:48 am  

christopher wrote:

Don't talk daft

Go on then, make your case for Walker.

Simple mine. Error prone, offers nothing in attack with the play constantly breaking down when he gets the ball. Poor when called upon to be last line of defence. Name a fb he is currently better than in SL. Harsh but so true.

Re: OUT MS 2019 | Matt Parcell - Hull Kingston Rovers : Fri Jun 28, 2019 10:51 am  

KaeruJim wrote:

Thought Parcell was good last night - agree with Brissers.

KR are similar to us in that they have some weak spots, maybe not as much talent but better balanced and play better as a team (Neary all other sides have been playing better as a team than us).

Key is how effectively we use the salary and quota spot freed up with recent moves - this has never been about Parcell and Lunt swapping, Dwyer has been starting for us anyway.

I too think Parcell is top quality and only kept out by an exceptional hooker in Dwyer for and I have said it for last 2 seasons I would have had Parcell in at half instead of Myler and would have given Dwyer Hooking shirt.
Like it of not Myler has been a consistent weak link ever since he joined

Re: OUT MS 2019 | Matt Parcell - Hull Kingston Rovers : Fri Jun 28, 2019 10:57 am  

dwyers a headless chicken though. spoils a lot of attacks. parcell by plenty

Re: OUT MS 2019 | Matt Parcell - Hull Kingston Rovers : Fri Jun 28, 2019 10:59 am  

moxi1 wrote:

Go on then, make your case for Walker.

Simple mine. Error prone, offers nothing in attack with the play constantly breaking down when he gets the ball. Poor when called upon to be last line of defence. Name a fb he is currently better than in SL. Harsh but so true.

He’s no more error prone than a lot of fullbacks, full back is a postion where errors are more pronounced

Saying he offers nothing in attack is ridiculous hes the second highest of our team for tackle busts for a start

He imo is currently better than

Shaul
Hampshire
Macintosh
Evalds

And a few others




And he is still only 19

Re: OUT MS 2019 | Matt Parcell - Hull Kingston Rovers : Fri Jun 28, 2019 11:02 am  

I can understand all the reasons why you got rid of Parcell, a lot of it makes sense, the baffling thing is why you let him come to us? We have been a hooker short of being a half decent side all year and if I was the Leeds hierarchy I'd have not help strengthen us at any cost

Re: OUT MS 2019 | Matt Parcell - Hull Kingston Rovers : Fri Jun 28, 2019 11:08 am  

barham red wrote:

I can understand all the reasons why you got rid of Parcell, a lot of it makes sense, the baffling thing is why you let him come to us? We have been a hooker short of being a half decent side all year and if I was the Leeds hierarchy I'd have not help strengthen us at any cost

Maybe your the only team that wanted him and could offer us a replacement in return, we’ll wait and see but Lunt could be a better fit for us at this moment in time

Ive also heard rumours Parcell was one of the players who was a disruptive element in the squad, how true that is I don’t know

[Fantastic Mr Catpiss]

Re: OUT MS 2019 | Matt Parcell - Hull Kingston Rovers : Fri Jun 28, 2019 11:14 am  

moxi1 wrote:

Hope you’re not joking. Walker is the weakest FB in the league. Quinlan before being injured last year was second to Barba in the league.

mate, i know you had a good win last night, and your feeling giddy, but don't be saying daft stuff like that.

Re: OUT MS 2019 | Matt Parcell - Hull Kingston Rovers : Fri Jun 28, 2019 11:30 am  

christopher wrote:

Maybe your the only team that wanted him and could offer us a replacement in return, we’ll wait and see but Lunt could be a better fit for us at this moment in time

Ive also heard rumours Parcell was one of the players who was a disruptive element in the squad, how true that is I don’t know

Think this is about right.

Re: OUT MS 2019 | Matt Parcell - Hull Kingston Rovers : Fri Jun 28, 2019 11:45 am  

christopher wrote:

Maybe your the only team that wanted him and could offer us a replacement in return, we’ll wait and see but Lunt could be a better fit for us at this moment in time

Ive also heard rumours Parcell was one of the players who was a disruptive element in the squad, how true that is I don’t know

I think they were more keen to get rid, than what they got in return. That element was just an opportunity that arose as a result. Parcell was much better for us than Dwyer, and a far better player, but that doesn't change the fact that for the club he had to go, and from a business persepctive going forward they had to take the opportunity to do that. Hull KR will still be down there, whether he was there or not.