: Thu Apr 16, 2009 9:34 pm  

Legless wrote:

Why?

The offence that caused the try to be disallowed was Webb was not behind the PTB, therefore out of play and unable to get involved until the next PTB.

Joynt was onside at the PTB, watch it again on YouTube. You can clearly see Joynt standing behind the PTB to the left.

Correct, as simple as that. Joynt was behind Sculthorpe and Cunningham when the ball was played, Webb was at least 5 metres in front of the Leeds player when the ball was played.

: Thu Apr 16, 2009 9:39 pm  

Pretty straight forward really. Just some of our lot couldn't seem to grasp the facts at the time.

It was all a conspiracy, as Pam.

: Fri Apr 17, 2009 9:30 am  

Glenn Quagmire wrote:

Pretty straight forward really. Just some of our lot couldn't seem to grasp the facts at the time.

It was all a conspiracy, as Pam.

[Fantastic Mr Catpiss]

: Fri Apr 17, 2009 10:13 am  

Saddened! wrote:

Hasn't it always been offside if you are ahead of the play the ball and get involved without getting behind the play the ball first? I remember it happening against Salford in a game I listened to on the radio in the Goulding days. The commentators were going on about how amateurish Salford were for being offside at the play the ball when in possession.

When it happened in the Airport derby I was screaming the house down for the referee to get him for offside and punched the air when he did. A Wire fan who watched it with me was laughing his head off at me, telling me he couldn't possibly be offside because Burrow played him on.

they changed the ruling a few years ago, i'm pretty sure the attacking side had to be 5 metres back from the play the ball, and all the ockers at london broncos kept getting penalised for it(dunno if it's just our refs) but they ended up changing the rule to be you can't advance past the ptb in attack to simplify it.

: Fri Apr 17, 2009 11:59 am  

Smurf wrote:

I may be mistaken but wasn't it because Webb was offside from the actual play the ball, making no attempt to get back into the line, and therefore he wasn't allowed to take part in that play?

Joynt is in view behind the play the ball for the Wide to West try, so its a completely different situation.

Yes everyone was behind the ball when it was played. This leeds fan either does not understand the rules or is just bitter. My guess is a bit of both.

: Fri Apr 17, 2009 1:19 pm  

IIRC Alan Hunte got penalised at CP for being in front of the PTB when Saints kicked downfield on the last tackle, even though he played no part in grounding the Wiganer (Hampson?) with the ball. Botica took the two points on offer. That game ended 8-8 and effectively gave the league trophy to the dirty cheating Pie-eaters as they had a superior points difference.

If you are in front of the PTB you are offside - end of.

: Fri Apr 17, 2009 2:17 pm  

Tony Catsmith wrote:

they changed the ruling a few years ago, i'm pretty sure the attacking side had to be 5 metres back from the play the ball, and all the ockers at london broncos kept getting penalised for it(dunno if it's just our refs) but they ended up changing the rule to be you can't advance past the ptb in attack to simplify it.

Honest question here. How could the refs enforce that, without having a touch judge or marker or something to indicate where the exact 5 m behind the PTB was, similar to what we have with the 'retiring 10 m' thing?

: Fri Apr 17, 2009 2:20 pm  

Legless wrote:

Honest question here. How could the refs enforce that, without having a touch judge or marker or something to indicate where the exact 5 m behind the PTB was, similar to what we have with the 'retiring 10 m' thing?

I think that was one of the problems.

: Fri Apr 17, 2009 10:04 pm  

Badwanger wrote:

IIRC Alan Hunte got penalised at CP for being in front of the PTB when Saints kicked downfield on the last tackle, even though he played no part in grounding the Wiganer (Hampson?) with the ball. Botica took the two points on offer. That game ended 8-8 and effectively gave the league trophy to the dirty cheating Pie-eaters as they had a superior points difference.

If you are in front of the PTB you are offside - end of.

Exactly its not a new rule at all. They only lost a game to the Bulls, we lost a championship to this rule.