: Fri May 22, 2009 1:29 am  

Wilkin/Sinfield and Pryce would be a good pairing.

Dont care what anyone says
Wilkin when called upon has always had great games at scrum half

Look at Scully - Man of Steel playing mainly at stand off(I think?)

Wilkin is a great player when given more responsibility. He is wasted as a second rower.

I rate Burrow, but doesnt give the direction longy gives on his day. Which is what England Needs.

Would have to be Sinfield or Wilkin for me, with Pryce
Burrow on the bench.

i dont know if I rate Mcguire or not, He doesnt seemed to have improved as a plyer at all in the last couple of years.

Lets hope Some youngsters progress in the next couple of years because we have lost a lot of quality english players in recent years, and we havnt replaced them

: Fri May 22, 2009 6:55 am  

saintcj wrote:

Wilkin/Sinfield and Pryce would be a good pairing.

Dont care what anyone says
Wilkin when called upon has always had great games at scrum half

Look at Scully - Man of Steel playing mainly at scrum half (I think?)

Wilkin is a great player when given more responsibility. He is wasted as a front rower.

I rate Burrow, but doesnt give the direction longy gives on his day. Which is what England Needs.

Would have to be Sinfield or Wilkin for me, with Pryce
Burrow on the bench.

i dont know if I rate Mcguire or not, He doesnt seemed to have improved as a plyer at all in the last couple of years.

Lets hope Some youngsters progress in the next couple of years because we have lost a lot of quality english players in recent years, and we havnt replaced them

Are you drunk!?

: Fri May 22, 2009 7:47 am  

saintcj wrote:

Wilkin/Sinfield and Pryce would be a good pairing.

Dont care what anyone says
Wilkin when called upon has always had great games at scrum half

Look at Scully - Man of Steel playing mainly at scrum half (I think?)

Wilkin is a great player when given more responsibility. He is wasted as a front rower.

I rate Burrow, but doesnt give the direction longy gives on his day. Which is what England Needs.

Would have to be Sinfield or Wilkin for me, with Pryce
Burrow on the bench.

i dont know if I rate Mcguire or not, He doesnt seemed to have improved as a plyer at all in the last couple of years.

Lets hope Some youngsters progress in the next couple of years because we have lost a lot of quality english players in recent years, and we havnt replaced them

Scully won it at stand off, not scrum half.
Wilkin is a second rower/loose forward, not front rower.

: Fri May 22, 2009 6:09 pm  

Scully a scrum half?!!!

He played most at either stand off or loose.

When scully moved from loose to stand off I thought he wouldn't make a stand off as long as he lived.

How wrong was I! He played his best rugby at 6 for saints and for GB.

: Fri May 22, 2009 11:16 pm  

I still get position names wrong.

Scully did have his best games at Stand Off
and
Wilkin has arguably had his best games at stand off/scrum half(which ever it was).

I think people underestimate Wilkins quality.

: Sat May 23, 2009 4:20 pm  

I think you overestimate it.

He can get away with it at SL level, he'd be as effective as Ricky Bibey there at international level.

As for Sinfield at 7, deary me today. Just like Wilkin he's not really good enough at the higher level that is Representative RL.