: Wed May 13, 2009 4:31 pm  

Billinge_Lump wrote:

I think part of the problem is that we are too focussed on what the Aussies are doing at times.

I agree with that.

A simple example is how this season our ruck has slowed and wasn't that in response to the wrestling used by the Aussies in the world cup? Instead of doing what I suggested ( ) and ignoring the Aussies, the RFL have slowed down the ruck (presumably) in an attempt to compete with the Aussies (bearing in mind this has happened post world cup). Kapow! What's happened with the Aussies? Their executive decision to have two refs (because since when have the Aussies taken a blind bit of notice of anyone else?) has speeded up the ruck. So now we are all out of step with the Aussies again. Had we just ignored the Aussies we would have still had an exciting game to watch and we would now be playing on a more level playing field so far as the ruck is concerned.

I do wish we would respect our own game.

: Wed May 13, 2009 4:34 pm  

Until we can develop athletes like the Aussies we will have no chance. They have backs who are as strong as our forwards and forwards who are more atheltic and as quick as our backs.

: Wed May 13, 2009 5:28 pm  

i think hargreaves wouldnt do badly against the french, aussies and kiwis not sure,

however could be worth ago i think people looks straight past him to graham as he over shadows bryn,

but bryn carts the ball up makes good metres, doesnt give pentalties away, i cant remember the last time he made a mistake, never misses tackles, he plays a lot of minutes on the sly,

and a massive plus for bryn is that he always always wins the floor more so imo than graham, he allows roby chance to scoot as his plays the balls are rapid. but i think because we have graham he gets over looked.

if crabtree and fielden are in with a shout then surely bryns up there as well

: Wed May 13, 2009 5:46 pm  

Jammer vs. Bryn: The Comparison.

Jammer vs. Bryn: The Comparison.

: Wed May 13, 2009 5:51 pm  

Carlos Alberto wrote: Jammer vs. Bryn: The Comparison. Thats not a comparison, its a bench mark!

Carlos Alberto wrote: Jammer vs. Bryn: The Comparison. Thats not a comparison, its a bench mark!

: Wed May 13, 2009 6:50 pm  

Ski wrote:

Bryn, in an England shirt.

I'll be back in a bit.

Nurse!

Get the mop.

There's been a spillage!

: Thu May 14, 2009 6:38 am  

vila_16 wrote:

i think hargreaves wouldnt do badly against the french, aussies and kiwis not sure,

however could be worth ago i think people looks straight past him to graham as he over shadows bryn,

but bryn carts the ball up makes good metres, doesnt give pentalties away, i cant remember the last time he made a mistake, never misses tackles, he plays a lot of minutes on the sly,

and a massive plus for bryn is that he always always wins the floor more so imo than graham, he allows roby chance to scoot as his plays the balls are rapid. but i think because we have graham he gets over looked.

if crabtree and fielden are in with a shout then surely bryns up there as well

A very good post, I agree in the most part. His lack of mistakes is something that may be overlooked, but is very relevant if you're comparing him to someone like S. Fielden.

However, while he won't let anyone down, I have the following reservations:
- he can look a bit toothless in the really tough games.
- he's not realistically going to be one of the top 6 british props by the end of the season.
- every club has a Bryn Hargreaves.

But, looking at it from another point of veiw, he's still very young for a prop - what level was Fozzard at when he was his age??

: Thu May 14, 2009 10:59 pm  

i agree every club does, but would we not need someone as solid as that in the england team who can play anywhere in the pack, whilst you assume morley and graham possibly the starters at prop and peacock at 2nd row,

morley - always guaranteed to give penalties and ageing
graham - winner a club level minutes wise can he do it international level
peacock - fantastic player but no spring chicken
burgess - can he bounce back

so then you look around the grounds for other young ? english props who can compete

personally i think bryn is at the top of a list of props with a ? next to their name

bryn
luke burgess
lynch
crabtree
personally not a fan of coley carvell and thackaray so from list of names there you are going to have to replace peacock and morley in the near future and i think bryn heads the pack, solid will do the job for robes , etc to get a roll on

in my opinion anyway

: Thu May 14, 2009 11:06 pm  

Billinge_Lump wrote:

You know they don't.

They are quite happy to tonk us every time they play us and then push their own comp as the highest standard.

I don't think you can tar all Aussies with the same brush. Whilst I'm sure there are many who are solely interested in their own competition, there are others - such as Wayne Bennett - who can see the benefits of a vibrant international game.

: Fri May 15, 2009 1:10 am  

Eurob0y wrote:

Until we can develop athletes like the Aussies we will have no chance. They have backs who are as strong as our forwards and forwards who are more atheltic and as quick as our backs.

I agree. Watching the Aus vs NZ test from the week past the one thing that stood out is the sheer athleticism and intensity of their players. Bar Lockyer, every one of their squad looked massive but extremely quick with it, and even Lockyer at what... 32? looked as fit as a fiddle and threw himself into everything.

The intensity and determination shown by the aussies (and kiwis too) for 80 minutes was a joy to watch and for me is where we are so behind on the international stage. That and the fact that the majority of their attacking/creative players would probably cope well in each others positions.