Gardner... : Fri Apr 24, 2009 9:03 pm  

Everyone is quick to slate Francis Meli when he makes mistakes, but jeez, how many trys do we conceed down Ade's wing.

Tonight reminded me of the Wigan match at the DW stadium recently, when he was caught in no mans land and Ainscough went over for 2 tries.

He gets caught in no mans land when defending kicks.

Re: Gardner... : Fri Apr 24, 2009 9:06 pm  

OoOGazOoO wrote:

Everyone is quick to slate Francis Meli when he makes mistakes, but jeez, how many trys do we conceed down Ade's wing.

Tonight reminded me of the Wigan match at the DW stadium recently, when he was caught in no mans land and Ainscough went over for 2 tries.

He gets caught in no mans land when defending kicks.

He's slow, but it's not his fault. If you look at the time the kicks were made there were three or four players on Gardner, they would have walked it in by passing wide too, he can't possibly cover that much ground when facing the wrong way.

Re: Gardner... : Fri Apr 24, 2009 9:15 pm  

Saddened! wrote:

He's slow, but it's not his fault. If you look at the time the kicks were made there were three or four players on Gardner, they would have walked it in by passing wide too, he can't possibly cover that much ground when facing the wrong way.

It's not his fault, then who's fault is it lol.

And in terms of Ade Gardner, I've always said it, and I'll say it again, he is a good winger at best, no world beater, and is average most of the time. He is blessed with having Gidley on his shoulder who sets up 99% of his tries.

Scott Donald, David Halley and Peter Fox are all better than Gardner in my opinion.

: Fri Apr 24, 2009 9:30 pm  

Look first at the fullback.

How many tackles does Wellens miss?

He defines average.

: Fri Apr 24, 2009 9:31 pm  

Rogues Gallery wrote:

Look first at the fullback.

How many tackles does Wellens miss?

He defines average.

Re: Gardner... : Fri Apr 24, 2009 9:48 pm  

Scott_HKR wrote:

It's not his fault, then who's fault is it lol.

And in terms of Ade Gardner, I've always said it, and I'll say it again, he is a good winger at best, no world beater, and is average most of the time. He is blessed with having Gidley on his shoulder who sets up 99% of his tries.

Scott Donald, David Halley and Peter Fox are all better than Gardner in my opinion.

Spot on imo.

Gardner is average and always has been but he's been made to look half decent by the centres at his side. He must have had the easiest job in world in the last few seasons playing outside of 2 ledgends like Lyon and Gidley.

He got found out in the world cup when even an average joe like Calderwood out played him.

He can ctach a ball and has half decent pace but that about the start and end of it all.

Re: Gardner... : Fri Apr 24, 2009 9:50 pm  

Gardner missed his partner in crime tonight. Gidley is a defensive rock.

Re: Gardner... : Fri Apr 24, 2009 9:52 pm  

Blobbynator wrote:

Gardner missed his partner in crime tonight. Gidley is a defensive rock.

He missed him in every aspect of his play from his great defence to his walk in try assists.

The vast majoirty of wingers would miss a player like him though.

: Fri Apr 24, 2009 9:58 pm  

Remember Gilmour played that centre and normally he plays the other centre.
Wing play has always been a partnership with the centre, two backs not used to playing along side each other will miscommunicate with each other.

: Fri Apr 24, 2009 10:09 pm  

Whilst I do agree that Gardner isn't a world beater, he was badly let down by Gilmour inside him tonight, in the second half especially, he seemed all over the show positionally.