I know this has been mentioned before, but how many people would like to see him back at the club? It seems more and more likely that he'll be leaving Wigan, and although he has never really hit good form since his Bradford days, playing with our more dominant pack may build his confidence up and get him back. Obviously we would have to talk seriously about a much lower chunk than he's on currently, but still what do you think.

No thanks. Ever forward

No. If he was on a significantly lower percentage of the cap space, really had a desire to play for Bradford, found some more consistant form, and was out of contract anytime soon then, possibly maybe.

But I dont think any of that is true and we should be developing our youngsters and looking forward. Any outside signing of a prop should be an impact type prop more in the vagana/feka type mould IMO.

NO.
Not an opinion based on emotion (+ or -) just not the player we need for next season.

Put me down for a maybe. If we could get on the right terms, ie reasonably cheap then I think given the right motivation he could do a job as an impact prop for us.

Cant see him as an impact prop (first up) he was rarely that with us and certainly not for the last few years at Wigan.
Best to look elsewhere for a genuine impacyt prop.

No thanks his days of being a top class rugby player have been gone a long time.

No Way - Would be a ridiculous signing

Lost his mojo. It was once a huge mojo, but it's been gone a while.

Average, ageing pack man. Wouldn't add anything to the squad in a Menzies-, Vagana- or even Solomona- kind of way.

Would be a totally illogical signing, we've already got young 'uns who do more in a game than him.

I seem to be in the minority here, but I feel Stuart is player who thrives on confidence and self belief.
Interesting Q & A [url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/rugby_league/super_league/wigan/8018531.stmhere[/url
In surroundings he feels comfortable in I think he could come good

I don't think you're at all in the minority, I think you're dead right, confidence, self-belief, mojo - cal it what you want, he has lost it. It would be great to think that he could get it back, but there's a saying, "never look back".

He's shown no signs since before he left us of the player he once was and this would be a huge risk, unless he came as a workaday squad member and was paid accordingly but I'd still rather we got on with promoting the youngsters, by a distance.

Definitely NO, apparently the try he scored against Wakefield at the weekend was his 3rd try for Wigan. Definitely not what we need.