Platty...... : Sun Jul 19, 2009 6:52 pm  

To be fair to Platty he was ok today. Most of the knock ons today came from poor passes to whoever dropped them. His try would have been a good one had it been allowed. I've been a critic this season and he has deserved criticism at times. Maybe the spell in the reserves has done him good? Maybe a few others could do with a spell there?
The ones who deserved criticism today were Newton, Sheriffe and Worincey.
Let's see Crossley get a run out next week and Donaldson should start next week and see how he goes. Keep rotating the young ones. When's Morro due back?

Re: Platty...... : Sun Jul 19, 2009 6:56 pm  

Spannerz wrote:

Let's see Crossley get a run out next week and Donaldson should start next week and see how he goes. Keep rotating the young ones. When's Morro due back?

I'd rather put Koppy back in than Crossley judging by reserves today. Is Koppy injured though?

Morro's not back for ages but I agree about Donaldson. Personally i'd be happy to see our pack start like this.


Lynch Godwin Scruton

Whitehead Burgess

Donaldson

Put Cook, Kopzcak, Langley & Newton on bench.

: Sun Jul 19, 2009 6:57 pm  

You have to remember Platt is personally responsible for global warming, the recession and for shooting JFK. It is important to know this when assessing his performances.

: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm  

Adeybull wrote:

You have to remember Platt is personally responsible for global warming, the recession and for shooting JFK. It is important to know this when assessing his performances.

He was Michael Jackson's doctor too.

Re: Platty...... : Sun Jul 19, 2009 10:42 pm  

Spannerz wrote:

To be fair to Platty he was ok today. Most of the knock ons today came from poor passes to whoever dropped them. His try would have been a good one had it been allowed. I've been a critic this season and he has deserved criticism at times. Maybe the spell in the reserves has done him good? Maybe a few others could do with a spell there?
The ones who deserved criticism today were Newton, Sheriffe and Worincey.
Let's see Crossley get a run out next week and Donaldson should start next week and see how he goes. Keep rotating the young ones. When's Morro due back?

ok for national league maybe still not good enough in big picture

Re: Platty...... : Sun Jul 19, 2009 10:43 pm  

Dennis Farrel wrote:

ok for national league maybe still not good enough in big picture

I'm sure we've met before

Re: Platty...... : Sun Jul 19, 2009 10:48 pm  

ex Bull Dog wrote:

I'm sure we've met before

who are you

Re: Platty...... : Sun Jul 19, 2009 11:00 pm  

Dennis Farrel wrote:

who are you

Oh come on pun..stew..I mean Dennis, you know

Re: Platty...... : Mon Jul 20, 2009 7:44 pm  

Spannerz wrote:

To be fair to Platty he was ok today. Most of the knock ons today came from poor passes to whoever dropped them. His try would have been a good one had it been allowed. I've been a critic this season and he has deserved criticism at times. Maybe the spell in the reserves has done him good? Maybe a few others could do with a spell there?
The ones who deserved criticism today were Newton, Sheriffe and Worincey.
Let's see Crossley get a run out next week and Donaldson should start next week and see how he goes. Keep rotating the young ones. When's Morro due back?

2 glaring mistakes from Newton within 3 mins of him returning, all i can say is im glad he's off to Wakey cos he's flattered to deceave in his time at Odsal!

: Mon Jul 20, 2009 8:00 pm  

Adeybull wrote:

You have to remember Platt is personally responsible for global warming, the recession and for shooting JFK. It is important to know this when assessing his performances.

I never realised he was as bad as that.

I'm still trying to get over the bloke sat behind me in the stand that was abusing him for a knock on around the base of the scrum when he wasn't even within 30 yards of the ball!!