Re: Cas 34 Bulls 30, all post-match discussion here : Fri Jul 15, 2011 1:20 pm  

id give him another yearwith a better back line if he still doesn't perform bye bye, briggs and Jeffries halfbacks with Southernwood as cover

Re: Cas 34 Bulls 30, all post-match discussion here : Fri Jul 15, 2011 1:44 pm  

I dont see a problem with herbert he seems to be getting better over the last few weeks especially, and i cant fault the guy against Cas - not sure its entirely fair giving the blame to these unheard of players because of how were playing, behind a good forward pack herbert can play well,

And as for Lynchy dont get me wrong i like him and just on his stats alone he is a workhorse BUT........... i dont think he is captain material, he didnt seem to be saying much when the team congregated behind the sticks after a Cas score

Re: Cas 34 Bulls 30, all post-match discussion here : Fri Jul 15, 2011 8:19 pm  

Well seeing everyone is on the back of Herbert. The guy is FAR from the worst player we have yet most seem to have the knives out for him.

Personally I would get rid of plenty before Herbert.

Re: Cas 34 Bulls 30, all post-match discussion here : Sat Jul 16, 2011 6:33 am  

mystic eddie wrote:

Well seeing everyone is on the back of Herbert. The guy is FAR from the worst player we have yet most seem to have the knives out for him.

Personally I would get rid of plenty before Herbert.

indeed. to be a success, it seems, you've got to score 50 points a game and miss no tackles.

Re: Cas 34 Bulls 30, all post-match discussion here : Sat Jul 16, 2011 6:57 am  

phillgee wrote:

indeed. to be a success, it seems, you've got to score 50 points a game and miss no tackles.

The thing is that there are too many sheep on here who just follow what certain people and agree with them because they must be too afraid to speak their own mind for fear of reprisals. They bag Herbert because everyone else seems to do so so they can join that cosy little group.

A sad indictment of this board.

Re: Cas 34 Bulls 30, all post-match discussion here : Sat Jul 16, 2011 8:40 am  

Don't get me wrong I like the guy, I just feel he's at the right team at the wrong time if you get me. He is improving but I rekon we need someone who is always good, a Briers, or a Brough, or even a Dureau. With Herbert I feel we arn't getting that flair a halfback needs.

Re: Cas 34 Bulls 30, all post-match discussion here : Sat Jul 16, 2011 9:13 am  

I think herbert would look outstanding in catalans team and I'm confident dureau wouldn't look as good in our team....