: Sun Apr 12, 2009 12:14 pm  

kingmonkey wrote:

Think you could be right.

Demetriou or Burgess? Hmmmmm..........

And don't get me started on rating Martin above Menzies. I'm not saying Martin isn't a good player because I quite rate him but do to do that over Menzies is crazy.

Read my analysis and you may figure out why

Burgess is a better player , but for what JD does for our team he would have to go infront of burgess in that posistion. For any other team i wouldnt hesitate in putting burgess infront of JD

: Sun Apr 12, 2009 12:17 pm  

!RYAN! wrote:

Thats the funniest thing ive read on here for ages i'll be there and i hope we murder you

Lets face it you havent had a lot to laugh about this season have you so its understandable. I think most of your fans would settle for a win and those what are hard to please at best a thrashing. It is only a game you know

: Sun Apr 12, 2009 12:18 pm  

Trinity Till Death wrote:

In the past when we've played the likes of Bradford, Leeds, Wigan and St Helens, i always think 'Wish i could watch him play in a Trinity shirt', but i can honestly say with possibly the exception of Burgess who is well out of sorts i wouldn't take any of you're players.

You don't think Andy Lynch would get in your team ahead of Wilkes, Snitch, Bibey, Sculthorpe or Moore?

: Sun Apr 12, 2009 12:34 pm  

DILLIGAF wrote:

You don't think Andy Lynch would get in your team ahead of Wilkes, Snitch, Bibey, Sculthorpe or Moore?

I'd rather have Wilkes, Moore and Stosic. Snitch plays second row and Sculthorpe does a job from the bench. I like how Bibb is coming along and our forwards are working really well as a unit. I don't imagine with a fully fit side that Bibey would play, but to be fair he has done a job when he's played.

Even with the injuries we've suffered our forwards are still playing superbly and Wilkes in particular with Stosic before his injury we're outstanding. Lynch is a good player but i can't say i'd be bothered if we signed him or not as i'm happy with what we've got.

: Sun Apr 12, 2009 12:59 pm  

Trinity Till Death wrote:

I'd rather have Wilkes, Moore and Stosic. Snitch plays second row and Sculthorpe does a job from the bench. I like how Bibb is coming along and our forwards are working really well as a unit. I don't imagine with a fully fit side that Bibey would play, but to be fair he has done a job when he's played.

Even with the injuries we've suffered our forwards are still playing superbly and Wilkes in particular with Stosic before his injury we're outstanding. Lynch is a good player but i can't say i'd be bothered if we signed him or not as i'm happy with what we've got.

Over Lynch?
Dear me.

: Sun Apr 12, 2009 1:12 pm  

Trinity Till Death wrote:

I'd rather have Wilkes, Moore and Stosic. Snitch plays second row and Sculthorpe does a job from the bench. I like how Bibb is coming along and our forwards are working really well as a unit. I don't imagine with a fully fit side that Bibey would play, but to be fair he has done a job when he's played.

Even with the injuries we've suffered our forwards are still playing superbly and Wilkes in particular with Stosic before his injury we're outstanding. Lynch is a good player but i can't say i'd be bothered if we signed him or not as i'm happy with what we've got.

.

: Sun Apr 12, 2009 1:18 pm  

redeverready wrote:

Menzies is more of a 6 than Martin is and he's never played 8 or 10.

Oh and you know that from your limited knowledge of watching both, oh dear another person who only see's the name - now I'm laughing.

: Sun Apr 12, 2009 1:20 pm  

Terry Monster wrote:

I see the guys point actually, I mean, who wouldn't want Steve Menzies over Tony Martin, anywhere on the field.

So basically you're a one man team. One narrow win and you're bragging already - how sad.

Menzies is a hero of mine and I would have him in my team - TEAM is the word here - is he part of a team?

: Sun Apr 12, 2009 1:21 pm  

I suggest that, notwithstanding how absurd or otherwise some of these comparisons might appear to some to be, it might be prudent to keep our powder dry till after the match? I've learnt from long experience that these sort of things have a nasty habit of coming back and biting you.

Like the chant of "easy" did at Cas the other week.

Anyway, player comparisons will always be subjective!

: Sun Apr 12, 2009 1:21 pm  

redeverready wrote:

:lol: .

Grow up son, points in the bag suggest your making a bigger fool of yourself than normal.