Re: GAME ON: Catalan Dragons v Warrington Wolves - 17:00:00 : Wed Aug 07, 2019 1:39 pm  

rollin thunder wrote:

So ge was fat overweight and not much cop, so he deserved having his lower leg smashed to bits by violent thuggery. Gibbs was a poop pkayer from a bygone age where pure violence made up for lack of athletic ability or talent.

So, just to be clear, the legal tackle didn't end his career as he went on to play for York & Scarborough into his 30s? I wouldn't wish that on anyone but Pearce wasn't good enough to play top level RL, which I would suggest is as much a reason. Gibbs was one of the most destructive players I have seen. To say he deliberately set out to end another players career is pathetic.

Re: GAME ON: Catalan Dragons v Warrington Wolves - 17:00:00 : Wed Aug 07, 2019 4:33 pm  

Catalans Dragons forward Kenny Edwards has been cleared of a charge of crowd incitement.

The New Zealander was accused by the Rugby Football League of inciting fans at the end of a tempestuous Super League match between the Dragons and Warrington in Perpignan last Saturday.

The match was marred by fighting on and off the pitch as tempers flared at the Stade Gilbert Brutus and Edwards was seen at one point being restrained by his club captain Remi Casty.

Re: GAME ON: Catalan Dragons v Warrington Wolves - 17:00:00 : Wed Aug 07, 2019 5:48 pm  

Disgraceful, the game is corrupt.

Re: GAME ON: Catalan Dragons v Warrington Wolves - 17:00:00 : Wed Aug 07, 2019 6:19 pm  

tigertot wrote:

So, just to be clear, the legal tackle didn't end his career as he went on to play for York & Scarborough into his 30s? I wouldn't wish that on anyone but Pearce wasn't good enough to play top level RL, which I would suggest is as much a reason. Gibbs was one of the most destructive players I have seen. To say he deliberately set out to end another players career is pathetic.

Yes it did end his career, his Hull career was over after that, yes he played a handful of lower league games but in essence he was finished after that viscous tackle. Yes I do belive Gibbs deliberately did it, you don't dive head first at someones prone isolated leg and not know the consequences of that, he set out to maim him and succeeded, Gibbs had a repution, for pure violence, especially on degensless kickers, flying elbow on Joe Lyndon in WCC another example, he was not a destructive player he was a thug, and thankfully players like him are not Longer in our game. I have seen some very tough players in my time and someone of them sometimes went too far, les Boyd, kurt Sorensen etr can. But they could all play a bit too, Gibbs could not.
If yo think those sort of tackles are fine then you are the pathetic one

Re: GAME ON: Catalan Dragons v Warrington Wolves - 17:00:00 : Wed Aug 07, 2019 10:35 pm  

reffy wrote:

Disgraceful, the game is corrupt.

Don't bother asking the RFL to justify their decision like I did when Zeb Taia took Joey Lussicks head off. I questioned why the panel said penalty sufficient, when if they had bothered to watch the match they would have realised the incompetent ref didn't even award a penalty !!

They sent me this.


Unfortunately it is not possible to enter into discussions regarding individual disciplinary cases.

Re: GAME ON: Catalan Dragons v Warrington Wolves - 17:00:00 : Wed Aug 07, 2019 11:16 pm  

Well the rfl have acted decisively, so just remember kids you can do what you like when you like to who ever you like on a rugby league field.

In the end the rfl will just sack the ref and all will be right.

Well played rfl, we move a step closer to footballs attitude to refs and a stride away from the way rugby union treats referees.

I know which I'd rather my child take up.

Re: GAME ON: Catalan Dragons v Warrington Wolves - 17:00:00 : Thu Aug 08, 2019 12:28 am  

Salford red all over wrote:

Don't bother asking the RFL to justify their decision like I did when Zeb Taia took Joey Lussicks head off.

They sent me this.


Unfortunately it is not possible to enter into discussions regarding individual disciplinary cases.

I have some sympathy with the RFL here. They'd never be given a minute's peace from the likes of Hill and Tomkins if they did otherwise.

Re: GAME ON: Catalan Dragons v Warrington Wolves - 17:00:00 : Thu Aug 08, 2019 12:58 am  

Kenneth Edwards is being let go by Catalans to join Huddersfield in 2020 perhaps because Catalans are tired of him being suspended.

Re: GAME ON: Catalan Dragons v Warrington Wolves - 17:00:00 : Thu Aug 08, 2019 5:33 am  

JEAN CAPDOUZE wrote:

Kenny Edwards is being let go by Catalans to join Huddersfield in 2020 perhaps because Catalans are tired of him being suspended.

Are you just starting your shift jean and perhaps a little fatigued?, it's not often you come up with an error like that with your insistance on using the full christian names.

Not being up to speed re Kenneth Edwards if he's out of contract at the end of the season then he wouldn't be let go by Catalans, just a thought as I know you will be all over it so to speak.

[Fantastic Mr Catpiss]

Re: GAME ON: Catalan Dragons v Warrington Wolves - 17:00:00 : Thu Aug 08, 2019 7:57 am  

JEAN CAPDOUZE wrote:

Kenneth Edwards is being let go by Catalans to join Huddersfield in 2020 perhaps because Catalans are tired of him being suspended.

i wouldn't worry about it, i'm sure they'll pick up another ill disciplined scrote that's been sacked by the nrl at some point.