Re: Player Ins and Outs : Mon Dec 16, 2019 5:40 pm  

I think bringing Sheens in and having a spine of

Owens

Craven/Smith

Tomkins

In the championship will be massive for us.

Re: Player Ins and Outs : Mon Dec 16, 2019 7:25 pm  

Steph Curry wrote:

Good signing for Widnes that

I agree with you...feels really weird doing so though !

Re: Player Ins and Outs : Tue Dec 17, 2019 1:32 am  

Budgiezilla wrote:

I agree with you...feels really weird doing so though !

Don't feel weird. The point is that Matthew Smith is just about at the playing standard of the current Widnes team.

Re: Player Ins and Outs : Tue Dec 17, 2019 7:44 am  

Pats plastic pitch wrote:

I think bringing Sheens in and having a spine of

Owens

Craven/Smith

Tomkins

In the championship will be massive for us.

Smith is a cog in the machine player. He has all the individual flare of a lump of coal but if he clicks as part of a team he’s a good player. So it depends what the team do, if they just expect him to perform magic he won’t and being in the championship won’t make any difference. If they all play their part then Smith will be a huge asset.

Re: Player Ins and Outs : Tue Dec 17, 2019 7:48 am  

JEAN CAPDOUZE wrote:

Don't feel weird. The point is that Matthew Smith is just about at the playing standard of the current Widnes team.

I'm sure Budge was talking to Steph.

Re: Player Ins and Outs : Tue Dec 17, 2019 9:19 am  

Fishermanscap wrote:

Smith is a cog in the machine player. He has all the individual flare of a lump of coal but if he clicks as part of a team he’s a good player. So it depends what the team do, if they just expect him to perform magic he won’t and being in the championship won’t make any difference. If they all play their part then Smith will be a huge asset.

I don’t and never have seen Smith as any kind of flare player or creative genius. Our strike will come from Owens and craven who were both fantastic last season.

He does however bring a wealth of experience and a decent kicking game, he’ll more than be an asset to Widnes in the championship.

Re: Player Ins and Outs : Tue Dec 17, 2019 1:42 pm  

Pats plastic pitch wrote:

I don’t and never have seen Smith as any kind of flare player or creative genius. Our strike will come from Owens and craven who were both fantastic last season.

He does however bring a wealth of experience and a decent kicking game, he’ll more than be an asset to Widnes in the championship.

Correct and probably should have stepped down to the Championship a few years back but who is going to turn down a year or two in Perpignan. Be interesting to see how he goes..

Re: Player Ins and Outs : Tue Dec 17, 2019 4:13 pm  

Pats plastic pitch wrote:

I don’t and never have seen Smith as any kind of flare player or creative genius. Our strike will come from Owens and craven who were both fantastic last season.

He does however bring a wealth of experience and a decent kicking game, he’ll more than be an asset to Widnes in the championship.

A pair of good halfbacks can change an honest, 'ordinary' team, into a very good one. You have two good half backs there.

Re: Player Ins and Outs : Tue Dec 17, 2019 5:26 pm  

Alan wrote:

A pair of good halfbacks can change an honest, 'ordinary' team, into a very good one. You have two good half backs there.

Yeah I think so. Rather have good half backs and ordinary outside backs rather than the other way around.

We still need a centre and at least one prop, then we start to look good.

Logan Tomkins and Matty Smith are very welcome additions.

Re: Player Ins and Outs : Tue Dec 17, 2019 5:27 pm  

Any whispers on who Saints and Wire are dual Reg’ing with? Without deflecting the topic of conversation. Leigh aren’t with Saints this year.