Re: Pauli Paulie sending off : Mon Jun 14, 2021 6:09 am  

SaleSlim wrote:

There are either some complete WUM's on here...................................................................

Not any more thanks to the Mods

whatever it was in whatever guises it's gone from here, and is infecting somewhere else....

Re: Pauli Paulie sending off : Wed Jun 16, 2021 4:06 pm  

Poky wrote:

Decent refs in the NRL? Go watch the Kobe Hetherington sending off this weekend and tell me they have decent refs. By far the worst sending off I have ever seen

So you found one bad decision from the NRL games this week, hardly compares with the number Kendall made in this one game. As I was saying with the Captains challenge they can question a decision in the NRL, and in most cases it usually proves the ref correct.

Re: Pauli Paulie sending off : Wed Jun 16, 2021 5:30 pm  

How did Pauli get on with his sending off ?

Re: Pauli Paulie sending off : Wed Jun 16, 2021 6:29 pm  

happyjack wrote:

How did Pauli get on with his sending off ?

No further action

Re: Pauli Paulie sending off : Thu Jun 17, 2021 8:27 am  

RogerMoore wrote:

So you found one bad decision from the NRL games this week, hardly compares with the number Kendall made in this one game. As I was saying with the Captains challenge they can question a decision in the NRL, and in most cases it usually proves the ref correct.

I think you will find that the captains challenge has been 50% successful this year so the ref was wrong 50% of the time. Thats not "usually proves the ref correct" now is it?

Re: Pauli Paulie sending off : Thu Jun 17, 2021 2:50 pm  

As I only watch the televised games in the UK I couldn't comment on the total actual percentage only on a perception of the games I actually watch. Are you stating the percentage that was given after 32 games this season.
Guess we'll never agree.

Re: Pauli Paulie sending off : Thu Jun 17, 2021 9:31 pm  

RogerMoore wrote:

As I only watch the televised games in the UK I couldn't comment on the total actual percentage only on a perception of the games I actually watch. Are you stating the percentage that was given after 32 games this season.
Guess we'll never agree.

I’m stating the 50% that the official NRL stats page gives.

But feel free to keep digging a hole rather than admit you were wrong

Re: Pauli Paulie sending off : Thu Jun 17, 2021 11:44 pm  

Poky wrote:

I’m stating the 50% that the official NRL stats page gives. So that would be a yes then



After 32 matches in 2021, teams are hovering at a close to 50 per cent success rate with 20 of 41 challenges successful. ( From NRL Stats)



But feel free to keep digging a hole rather than admit you were wrong

So far you came up with 1 bad decision in a weekend of NRL games, when as I said this thread already highlights more than that in one game here.

Nothing in any of that seems to make me wrong.

Referee performance is on the whole subjective, you seem to think it is better in Superleague, I think it's better in NRL, end of subject.