Re: New Stadium Site Update Thread!!! : Wed Dec 01, 2010 9:25 am  

BartonFlyer wrote:

I really don't think it's an issue of mediocity of ambition within the club - the inital plans were stunning, but events just happened to knock that off course.

I agree a national RL stadium would be superb, but first you'd have have to get the RFL to back it (and they seem more interested in pouring good money after bad with the likes of Harlequins and Crusaders!), then you'd have to get all the other chairmen to agree - a bit like pushing water uphill!!

For me, the fact we are getting a new stadium (with room for expansion if things go well) and the board have obviously put money into recruitment and strengthening the team next season all bodes well - please, please let's get behind the club and stop whinging - IF folk are a bit disappointed then just keep it to yourself and put out some positive signals instead.

We all need to do what we can to promote Salford City Reds in this great new opportunity.

Any idea how the stadium will be run , ie who will be making the decisions ?

Re: New Stadium Site Update Thread!!! : Wed Dec 01, 2010 9:37 am  

Starbug wrote:

Any idea how the stadium will be run , ie who will be making the decisions ?

Think its Salford Council with Peel!!! Were basically just using the stadium to play.

Re: New Stadium Site Update Thread!!! : Wed Dec 01, 2010 9:40 am  

BartonFlyer wrote:

I really don't think it's an issue of mediocity of ambition within the club - the inital plans were stunning, but events just happened to knock that off course.

I agree a national RL stadium would be superb, but first you'd have have to get the RFL to back it (and they seem more interested in pouring good money after bad with the likes of Harlequins and Crusaders!), then you'd have to get all the other chairmen to agree - a bit like pushing water uphill!!

For me, the fact we are getting a new stadium (with room for expansion if things go well) and the board have obviously put money into recruitment and strengthening the team next season all bodes well - please, please let's get behind the club and stop whinging - IF folk are a bit disappointed then just keep it to yourself and put out some positive signals instead.

We all need to do what we can to promote Salford City Reds in this great new opportunity.

Re: New Stadium Site Update Thread!!! : Wed Dec 01, 2010 10:01 am  

PIPO wrote:

Think its Salford Council with Peel!!! Were basically just using the stadium to play.

Oh dear ! , never mind

Re: New Stadium Site Update Thread!!! : Wed Dec 01, 2010 10:08 am  

See this is the thing with this forum these days, and one reason I try to abstain from posting as much, I and a couple of others have expressed an opinion regarding the design of the stadium and yet again we’re being made out to be "having a go" I Don’t like the design but I do love the fact we're actually getting the new stadium (me and a few others have played our part in getting it here). Like I've said before I just believe we could have got something more iconic in some way, go back to the initial plans (The ones from the summer of this year not the ones from 10 years ago) and at least it had a few distinguishing features. Now it's bland, bland, bland.

Look at other new stadia which have popped up over the past few years and how aesthetically pleasing they look and then check out cost per space!

This has nothing to do with the efforts of the club, I thank Salford City Council and Peel greatly for getting this for us, and I'm not trying to put it down or having a whinge for whinging sake, I like everyone else, can't wait to see it going up and of course completed, I know fully the benefits the stadium will bring and I've tried my best to convince many for a long time that this stadium would happen, including a number from this forum, and been met with a lot of negativity but I've continued to promote the idea.

I just don't particularly like the look of it, it's not a crime.

Rant. Over. Thank you.

Re: New Stadium Site Update Thread!!! : Wed Dec 01, 2010 10:10 am  

Starbug wrote:

Oh dear ! , never mind

To be fair we have an excellent relationship with SCC, it's them that have got this Stadium where it is now, I think we'll be Ok.

Re: New Stadium Site Update Thread!!! : Wed Dec 01, 2010 10:20 am  

Bigpev wrote:

what about Leeds?

Leeds - have redeveloped headingly to a standard required by the RFL and the RFL wont tell Leeds what to do
Hull KR - just secured funds to redevelop the stadium
Hull - new stadium
Warrinton - new stadium
Huddersfield - new stadium
Wigan - new stadium
Salford - new stadium plans
Saints - new stadium plans
Bradford - new stadium plans
Cass - new stadium plans
Wakefield - new stadium plans

The below 3 dont matter as they can do what they want with the full backing of the RFL;
Crusaders
Quinns
Catalan

The fact is we couldnt redevelope the Willows to the "required" standard, Im almost certain this was looked at and with the limited space and surrounding area plus cost just wasnt feasible.
Whether all the above planned builds happen is another matter, I would just like to see ours built and us playing in it, as was previously said its what we're getting, but has the provision for expansion.

Re: New Stadium Site Update Thread!!! : Wed Dec 01, 2010 10:43 am  

king of the shed wrote:

To be fair we have an excellent relationship with SCC, it's them that have got this Stadium where it is now, I think we'll be Ok.

I hope you are right , because if you are wrong , it could be the biggest mistake your club ever makes

Re: New Stadium Site Update Thread!!! : Wed Dec 01, 2010 11:24 am  

Starbug wrote:

That'll be the drugs

Ha. If only. I'm one of those clean living types which leaves me with some unanswered questions...

Re: New Stadium Site Update Thread!!! : Wed Dec 01, 2010 11:37 am  

BartonFlyer wrote:

I really don't think it's an issue of mediocity of ambition within the club - the inital plans were stunning, but events just happened to knock that off course.

I agree a national RL stadium would be superb, but first you'd have have to get the RFL to back it (and they seem more interested in pouring good money after bad with the likes of Harlequins and Crusaders!), then you'd have to get all the other chairmen to agree - a bit like pushing water uphill!!

For me, the fact we are getting a new stadium (with room for expansion if things go well) and the board have obviously put money into recruitment and strengthening the team next season all bodes well - please, please let's get behind the club and stop whinging - IF folk are a bit disappointed then just keep it to yourself and put out some positive signals instead.

We all need to do what we can to promote Salford City Reds in this great new opportunity.

As much as I may not agree with a few of your points I do appreciate them all the same. Indeed, I recognise my personal outlook on this matter is somewhat more radical and beyond the consensus. Neverthless, I mean no harm to the club and certainly don't feel as though I'm "whinging". Merely expressing an alternative opinion. If anything, my angst lies at the door of British society which still seems to be biased in favour of the south-east/affluent. It's almost as though 'thinking-big' is a crime if you don't happen to be from the right part of the country. Indeed, I also feel that this particular mindset has been adopted by the RL community. Self-fulfilling prophecy and all that... Hey, who knows. "I only know one thing; I know nothing." (Socrates.)

I fully expect alternative opinions to be aired in this debate. Which is cool. But, I mean not to be rude but that's all I wish to contribute on the matter.