[Fantastic Mr Catpiss]

Re: 2024/25 out of season mind occupier #1 : Thu Oct 31, 2024 10:38 am  

Wires71 wrote:

Maybe Michael Monaghan on the bench.
Johnson at full back.

Honourable Mentions

Greg Mackey
Nathan Wood
Matt King
Grose
Hicks
Darren Burns
Les Davison (?)
Sid Domic




It may be easier to tell you who wont be in it.

Roach
Asotasi
Lama Tasi
Sitaleki Akauola
Sims
Inglis
Sturm
Roberts
McGuire (Bruce)
McGuire (Josh)
Appo
Eagar
Felton
Georgallis
Gillies
Marquet
Nutley
Pomeroy
Rodwell
Sandow
Sullivan
Teitzel
Walters
Leikvoll
Drinkwater
Sam Kasiano
Gelling
Jason Clark
Jake Mamo
Goodwin
Blake Austin








Wow we need to change our Australian scouts.

bit harsh on goodwin

Re: 2024/25 out of season mind occupier #1 : Thu Oct 31, 2024 10:41 am  

MrMatt wrote:

Des Drummond

Pedant alert. Jamaica is in the Northern Hemisphere.

Re: 2024/25 out of season mind occupier #1 : Thu Oct 31, 2024 10:55 am  

Fantastic Mr Catpiss wrote:

bit harsh on goodwin

I just put him in the list of those who would not trouble the "Best Team".

Do you think we would get in it?

Re: 2024/25 out of season mind occupier #1 : Thu Oct 31, 2024 10:56 am  

ratticusfinch wrote:

Honourable mention to Duane Mann also - what a player

Great shout.

Re: 2024/25 out of season mind occupier #1 : Thu Oct 31, 2024 10:58 am  

MrMatt wrote:

Des Drummond
Toa-Kohe Love
Tawera Nikau

Nikau can F.R.O after his barbeque and that shambles that followed. Least he had a bit of biff.

Re: 2024/25 out of season mind occupier #1 : Thu Oct 31, 2024 12:17 pm  

St Helens Wolf wrote:

Pedant alert. Jamaica is in the Northern Hemisphere.

Shucks........maybe I should have read the opening post properly.

[Fantastic Mr Catpiss]

Re: 2024/25 out of season mind occupier #1 : Thu Oct 31, 2024 12:42 pm  

Wires71 wrote:

I just put him in the list of those who would not trouble the "Best Team".

Do you think we would get in it?

Depends on the criteria, which is never clarified on these things.(which always narks me when i see jamie lyon mentioned in all time SL list)

If tenure isn't a weighted value, you could argue he had 2 very very good seasons with us, good defender, good try scorer. Saved the 2019 challenge cup final with THAT tackle.


I would argue the same with gillies, now i'm not advocating for him to be in a team of all time, but its harsh to include him with some crap, as he was very good, and responsible for scott wilson scoring a hat full of tries, Kohe-love finishing (joint?) top of the try scoring charts, and i think whoever played right ring(roach for the start of the season) scored a hat full of tries also.

edit, just looking back, i'd certainly have goodwin in at centre over monaghan, and, its surprised me to see Domic included in your list of honourable mentions who'd wager was no better or worse than goodwin was during his time here.

I'd also have leikvoll in the honourable mentions list, big man, made his tackles, decent offload game, always found the floor for quick ptb's, and got a few years out of him. you put him in this team, it would make all the difference in the world.

Re: 2024/25 out of season mind occupier #1 : Thu Oct 31, 2024 1:11 pm  

Mamo should be in the honourable mentions list purely for his post match interviews.

Re: 2024/25 out of season mind occupier #1 : Thu Oct 31, 2024 1:26 pm  

Fantastic Mr Catpiss wrote:

Depends on the criteria, which is never clarified on these things.(which always narks me when i see jamie lyon mentioned in all time SL list)

If tenure isn't a weighted value, you could argue he had 2 very very good seasons with us, good defender, good try scorer. Saved the 2019 challenge cup final with THAT tackle.


I would argue the same with gillies, now i'm not advocating for him to be in a team of all time, but its harsh to include him with some crap, as he was very good, and responsible for scott wilson scoring a hat full of tries, Kohe-love finishing (joint?) top of the try scoring charts, and i think whoever played right ring(roach for the start of the season) scored a hat full of tries also.

edit, just looking back, i'd certainly have goodwin in at centre over monaghan, and, its surprised me to see Domic included in your list of honourable mentions who'd wager was no better or worse than goodwin was during his time here.

I'd also have leikvoll in the honourable mentions list, big man, made his tackles, decent offload game, always found the floor for quick ptb's, and got a few years out of him. you put him in this team, it would make all the difference in the world.

Yeah fair comments.

Id have matt king at centre over monaghan.

The honourable mentions was quite subjective based on my emotions around the player and the circumstances they joined. The list of those that don't make the "best team" does include some decent players and some not so. I never used the word crap though.

No right or wrong answers

Re: 2024/25 out of season mind occupier #1 : Thu Oct 31, 2024 3:42 pm  

Johns was crap in 2 of the 3 games he played for us.