: Sat Jun 27, 2009 7:06 pm  

robbierotten wrote:

Ryanwire

your comments are poor your just talking nonsense mate

be more specific which of those players am i wrong about

: Sat Jun 27, 2009 7:26 pm  

sean11evo11 wrote:

The Myler deal is 100% done why does everyone keep on going on about it

it will be 100% when it's annouced and not before

: Sat Jun 27, 2009 8:17 pm  

getdownmonkeyman wrote:

2003 we were still at Wilderspool haemorrhaging cash. 2004/2005 for mine was a period of stability, 2006 onwards, which is pretty much our time spending the full cap, this would have been our time to start imposing ourselves on finals, but we have no divine right to oust the likes of Leeds and Saints.

We must have had some cash in the late 80's/early 90's as we were signing the likes of Andy Gregory and Jonathan Davies. From memory it was about 95/96 where we really started to hit the skids.

Regarrding Smith, if Leeds were so poop hot, why had they not won anything since 1999? He gained them a pot by his second season.

Hertel (sponsors) bankrolled Davies IIRC (Widnes could not pay his contract), not sure about Andy Greg but we were semi-pro then anyway. Period 2006 onwards wasnt to do with divine rights, we were'nt even on the same page to compete due to choice of coach.

It would be interesting to know why, this skint club (as you moot), could afford the likes of Blake, Boyd, Roach, Davidson et al in a pre-SL era without TV money.

: Sat Jun 27, 2009 8:21 pm  

mark_m wrote:

You could make a case for Monaghan although the player has to take some of the responsibility.

Didn't we ruin Halliwell? I remember people with bucket collections trying to keep him as he was THAT good. Then he went into oscurity after our touch.

Maybe people are thinking we ruined Noone, Hulse, Durbin, Alstead, Sibbit too (the list is long). Or maybe they were never, ever, good enough.

We didn't seem to ruin Scully or Harris.

: Sat Jun 27, 2009 8:31 pm  

Wires71 wrote:

Didn't we ruin Halliwell? I remember people with bucket collections trying to keep him as he was THAT good. Then he went into oscurity after our touch.

Maybe people are thinking we ruined Noone, Hulse, Durbin, Alstead, Sibbit too (the list is long). Or maybe they were never, ever, good enough.

We didn't seem to ruin Scully or Harris.

first point,bucket colllections,never happened,2nd point all these were not goood enough anyway,third point our crooked chairman sold them and trousered the cash,hence simon came in and sorted the clubs finances out and here we are.

: Sat Jun 27, 2009 11:28 pm  

Live Wired wrote:

How would moving from Salford to Warrington improve him,when we've got a history of ruining players.

Personally I dont want him here.Does nobody remember the Iestyn Harris saga?

simple..
1... he`ll be at a better club with better players
2...playing under the national teams coach..
3...better chance of honours
4...better stadium better atmosphere
5..not involved in a bottom of the table dogfight..

: Sat Jun 27, 2009 11:29 pm  

Wires71 wrote:

Hertel (sponsors) bankrolled Davies IIRC (Widnes could not pay his contract), not sure about Andy Greg but we were semi-pro then anyway. Period 2006 onwards wasnt to do with divine rights, we were'nt even on the same page to compete due to choice of coach.

It would be interesting to know why, this skint club (as you moot), could afford the likes of Blake, Boyd, Roach, Davidson et al in a pre-SL era without TV money.

Semi-pro in 1985? Very minimal pro, with Mike Gregory being the only fulltime player.

Have you read what I wrote? Up to the mid-90's we were competitve, frpm about '96 onwards we went to bits.

: Sat Jun 27, 2009 11:47 pm  

Wires71 wrote:

Hertel (sponsors) bankrolled Davies IIRC (Widnes could not pay his contract), not sure about Andy Greg but we were semi-pro then anyway. Period 2006 onwards wasnt to do with divine rights, we were'nt even on the same page to compete due to choice of coach.

It would be interesting to know why, this skint club (as you moot), could afford the likes of Blake, Boyd, Roach, Davidson et al in a pre-SL era without TV money.

We couldn't afford them.Thats the reason we nearly went bust and came close to getting relagated.

[Fantastic Mr Catpiss]

: Sat Jun 27, 2009 11:56 pm  

Live Wired wrote:

Live Wired wrote: How would moving from Salford to Warrington improve him,when we've got a history of ruining players.

Personally I dont want him here.Does nobody remember the Iestyn Harris saga?


anything a bit more recent that 13 years ago?


or clarification on how we 'ruined' harris


Who mentioned ruining Harris?
The point about Harris is,that he was poached by Leeds via a 3rd party,the same is happening with us and Myler.and imo,the sooner the rfl,clamp downt on this the better,just to prove that the franchise system works and not that the farce that its turned into.

And imo,the sooner

well you mentioned harris in the same post about ruining players, say wot yer mean will ya!


Secondly, you know this third party that 'poached' harris, was it st helens or alex murphy?

: Sun Jun 28, 2009 8:23 am  

It was when he was away on international duty,ims.