Re: Signings - Ins & Outs. : Wed Oct 07, 2015 12:27 pm  

Spencer lazy?! That's a new one! I hope the board and fowls don't think like you oggy, spencer is a top front row prospect. He may be undercooked due to injury perhaps but never lazy. What happens when hock, moi moi and golden retire? Which will be in the next year hock perhaps year after. The future of the club lies in Emmett, Hopkins, spencer, sarsfield, with a couple of older heads for experience sake. It's no good getting rid of these quality young players to make the grade to SL, only to find that everybody in the squad deteriorates all at the same time. We need that balance in age.

Re: Signings - Ins & Outs. : Wed Oct 07, 2015 12:42 pm  

I'd keep spencer over Acton, Barlow must stay for me too ! Any new on whether Bob will be with us next year heard rumours he's off?

Re: Signings - Ins & Outs. : Wed Oct 07, 2015 2:28 pm  

renniethebear wrote:

Spencer lazy?! That's a new one! I hope the board and fowls don't think like you oggy, spencer is a top front row prospect. He may be undercooked due to injury perhaps but never lazy. What happens when hock, moi moi and golden retire? Which will be in the next year hock perhaps year after. The future of the club lies in Emmett, Hopkins, spencer, sarsfield, with a couple of older heads for experience sake. It's no good getting rid of these quality young players to make the grade to SL, only to find that everybody in the squad deteriorates all at the same time. We need that balance in age.

Correct rennie.

Re: Signings - Ins & Outs. : Wed Oct 07, 2015 7:32 pm  

Spence gets caught out in the line time and time again and he takens a maximum 3 drives when he's on!!! Not saying he's a bad player but simply not enough room for him for me! Hopkins is a good young player keep emmit on board! If Bailey doesn't happen if keep spencer but he's not the player everyone seems too think he is

Re: Signings - Ins & Outs. : Wed Oct 07, 2015 9:02 pm  

To be fair, maybe it's not been Tom's best season (when he has been given a game) but I wouldn't write him off just yet. He seems to have lost some weight, maybe Tom needs to 'bulk up' and eat some Pies !

Re: Signings - Ins & Outs. : Wed Oct 07, 2015 9:02 pm  

oggy123 wrote:

Spence ....... he takens a maximum 3 drives when he's on

It is obvious you don't rate him but don't exaggerate to try and prove your point.

Re: Signings - Ins & Outs. : Thu Oct 08, 2015 8:31 am  

Spenner was best prop in comp in 2014 season, must stay!

Re: Signings - Ins & Outs. : Thu Oct 08, 2015 8:33 am  

Major surgery at the end of 2014 curtailed his 2015 season imo, a great pre season and we will have a bigger and fitter Spenner back imo

Re: Signings - Ins & Outs. : Thu Oct 08, 2015 9:42 am  

No doubting he's a good player I'm comparing to the options we currently have moi moi hock Hopkins emmit and Weston all ahead of him! With the players we have brought in we can't accomadate people! He would be good cover and we need it but can we afford it??

Re: Signings - Ins & Outs. : Thu Oct 08, 2015 10:50 am  

We also have this problem in the half's if Chase comes, who goes ? Brierley,Ridy or Reynolds?