Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Mon Aug 09, 2021 3:42 am  

Keiththered wrote:

Not if the proposed system is introduced. You’ll have to wait until the end of 2022 season for that pleasure, it will only delay the inevitable. I’m afraid I cannot see you finishing 10th out of fourteen. You will need almost a new team. Effort will not be enough you will need skill as well. The likes of Joel Tomkins will not be enough.

You do realise that you will be enjoying the same pleasure at the end of 2022

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Mon Aug 09, 2021 5:01 am  

Cokey wrote:

You do realise that you will be enjoying the same pleasure at the end of 2022

Maybe, time will tell but we have made quality signings and resignings. You have not made any, so far. In fact your better players such as they are seem to be on the way out. You are well behind the eight ball. A position we found ourselves in over the last few years. It is a difficult situation to get out of as normally players will only sign for likely relegation candidates as a last resort. Having a proven coach enabled us to attract players of quality last time and so we have improved our position on last year, at least so far, whilst you signed a number our our players, the team that finished bottom thanks to the Canadians dropping out. That should have given you a bit of a clue about your chances this year. I do hope your new coach can pull things around as I fully appreciate the situation you are in. Well not quite as we have never gone so long without winning a match.

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Mon Aug 09, 2021 7:05 am  

Keiththered wrote:

Not if the proposed system is introduced. You’ll have to wait until the end of 2022 season for that pleasure, it will only delay the inevitable. I’m afraid I cannot see you finishing 10th out of fourteen. You will need almost a new team. Effort will not be enough you will need skill as well. The likes of Joel Tomkins will not be enough.

Again I do realise what situation we will be in , if we don’t go down ,and it could be just giving us a reprieve,with 4 going down out of 14 it will be extremely difficult and again I agree we will need a new team , we will need a virtual new team anyway ,as most are leaving at the end of this season .

And to survive we will need to recruit quality in abundance , I’m sure Derek knows this as well though ,as for Joel Tomkins ?Im hoping the first of a few quality players to arrive , you have to start somewhere , we have now signed him ,2 Aussies , Joe Mellor , I’m hoping Brierley and James Bell sign again ,maybe Sidlow ,the rest it will up to the Coach , again I’m not sure if we will get one but apparently Derek already has once in mind and is just waiting to announce him .

I’m hopeful of our future , hopeful being the word , but I’m also a realist IF we want to become a top 10 side then we need drastic measures in recruitment , or we are just marking time till we go down again .

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Mon Aug 09, 2021 7:10 am  

Cokey wrote:

You do realise that you will be enjoying the same pleasure at the end of 2022

Derek I think ourselves , Salford , Wakey , Hudds , Hull KR , and the 2 possible oromotedClubs if it happens all realise the extreme mountain they will have to climb to get into the proposed top 10.

My question is this season we started on a lower amount of Central Funding ,because we where a new team to SL , next season we won’t be a new team , does this mean we will on the same footing asSalford , Hudds ,and Wakey ?And will the 2 promoted teams be on a less amount as we were ?

It will be interesting to see what occurs .

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Mon Aug 09, 2021 7:44 am  

The Charlie Caroli wrote:

Again I do realise what situation we will be in , if we don’t go down ,and it could be just giving us a reprieve,with 4 going down out of 14 it will be extremely difficult and again I agree we will need a new team , we will need a virtual new team anyway ,as most are leaving at the end of this season .

And to survive we will need to recruit quality in abundance , I’m sure Derek knows this as well though ,as for Joel Tomkins ?Im hoping the first of a few quality players to arrive , you have to start somewhere , we have now signed him ,2 Aussies , Joe Mellor , I’m hoping Brierley and James Bell sign again ,maybe Sidlow ,the rest it will up to the Coach , again I’m not sure if we will get one but apparently Derek already has once in mind and is just waiting to announce him .

I’m hopeful of our future , hopeful being the word , but I’m also a realist IF we want to become a top 10 side then we need drastic measures in recruitment , or we are just marking time till we go down again .

I’m sure Derek Beaumont is well aware of what is needed. If his past record is anything to go by he has little idea of how to bring it about. His leadership over the past few seasons has left a lot to be desired. Being a passionate fan is not enough and he has proved it.

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Mon Aug 09, 2021 12:17 pm  

Gone off topic.
As Sky pointed out was not a try but not for the reason thought on the ground.The most blatant inconsistency of the ref never mind any card issue

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Mon Aug 09, 2021 2:14 pm  

Vancouver Leyther wrote:

Question on the final disallowed try question.
Liam Hood is clearly offside when the kick goes up

.

That is why the try was disallowed.

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Mon Aug 09, 2021 5:33 pm  

Sorry, in my annoyance did not make myself clear yes Hood was off side. I was referring to kr try when kr man was within 10 yards of our man fielding kick so penalty to us,probably not a knock as thought on the ground, but close, deffo no try.

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Mon Aug 09, 2021 9:40 pm  

Usually you hear the shout from the ref telling the players offside to stay back. For me the video ref is concentrating on the knock on, and forgets the rules of the game with Crooks onside.

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Mon Aug 09, 2021 11:00 pm  

reffy wrote:

That is why the try was disallowed.

Thanks Reffy, so the HKR try should have been disallowed for the same reason.
Very frustrating.