Squads for Edinburgh : Thu Apr 30, 2009 2:12 pm  

Salford City Reds squad

Sibbit, Myler, Henry, Jewitt, Turner, Smith, Wilshere, Cashmere, Alker, Stapleton, Goulding, Parker, Swain, Sidlow, Littler, Leuluai, Paul, Adamson, Ratchford.

Harlequins RL squad

Clubb, Dorn, Gafa, Gardner, Golden, Heckenberg, Howell, Kaye, McCarthy-Scarsbrook, Melling, Orr, Purdham, Randall, Robinson, Sharp, Temata, Ward, Wells, Williamson.

Heckenberg but not Haggerty in the squad.

Picks itself really, Gardner and Kaye to miss out.

Re: Squads for Edinburgh : Thu Apr 30, 2009 2:27 pm  

The Penguin wrote:

Salford City Reds squad

Sibbit, Myler, Henry, Jewitt, Turner, Smith, Wilshere, Cashmere, Alker, Stapleton, Goulding, Parker, Swain, Sidlow, Littler, Leuluai, Paul, Adamson, Ratchford.

Harlequins RL squad

Clubb, Dorn, Gafa, Gardner, Golden, Heckenberg, Howell, Kaye, McCarthy-Scarsbrook, Melling, Orr, Purdham, Randall, Robinson, Sharp, Temata, Ward, Wells, Williamson.

Heckenberg but not Haggerty in the squad.

Picks itself really, Gardner and Kaye to miss out.

Not sure about that - Gardener has been doing quite well and didn't look out of his depth last Friday, he is a big strong unit. Kaye - well almost every other team does the 2 hooker rotation and I think we suffered in a couple of games (Catalann for sure) without it.

Re: Squads for Edinburgh : Thu Apr 30, 2009 2:28 pm  

Paddock Punter wrote:

Not sure about that - Gardener has been doing quite well and didn't look out of his depth last Friday, he is a big strong unit. Kaye - well almost every other team does the 2 hooker rotation and I think we suffered in a couple of games (Catalann for sure) without it.

From what I've seen Gardner's defence is suspect. Looked all at sea against Hull KR.

Re: Squads for Edinburgh : Thu Apr 30, 2009 2:40 pm  

The Penguin wrote:

Salford City Reds squad

Sibbit, Myler, Henry, Jewitt, Turner, Smith, Wilshere, Cashmere, Alker, Stapleton, Goulding, Parker, Swain, Sidlow, Littler, Leuluai, Paul, Adamson, Ratchford.

Harlequins RL squad

Clubb, Dorn, Gafa, Gardner, Golden, Heckenberg, Howell, Kaye, McCarthy-Scarsbrook, Melling, Orr, Purdham, Randall, Robinson, Sharp, Temata, Ward, Wells, Williamson.

Heckenberg but not Haggerty in the squad.

Picks itself really, Gardner and Kaye to miss out.

Not sure if i would have Heckenberg playing so soon after injuring himself, have Karl playing prop again instead of SR, we will still have 4 props in the squad, Heckenberg and Gardner to miss out for me.

: Thu Apr 30, 2009 2:55 pm  

I think it be either Wells or Gardner to miss out(yesi know Gardner being playing well, but my choice from the backs. I expect it be Hecks from the forwards only going on fact he was injuried.

Personally i would try and stick with as much as the same Squad as last two weeks. Edinburgh have a wide big pitch so might suit someone like Gardner with his speed.

As for Salford Squad thought they were meant to be full of injuries, dont look bad to me

Re: Squads for Edinburgh : Thu Apr 30, 2009 2:57 pm  

The Penguin wrote:

From what I've seen Gardner's defence is suspect. Looked all at sea against Hull KR.

I cant remember too clearly but wasnt it the other wing they kept getting through on?

Re: Squads for Edinburgh : Thu Apr 30, 2009 5:15 pm  

tim791 wrote:

Not sure if i would have Heckenberg playing so soon after injuring himself

With Heckenberg injured on and off a lot, I think it will be too much of a risk to bring him back this weekend.