Greg Florimos Boots wrote:
This thread has made me chuckle.
Good for you. The do say laughter is the best medicine, so it's important we all find a reason to smile every day.
Greg Florimos Boots wrote:
In one off games against SL teams the top end Championship teams have more than held their own.
How many championship sides beat SL sides last year in competitive games? I ask, because holding your own in a one off is hardly the same as facing 4 SL sides all fighting for survival and all aware that +/- will be key, but if there was an upset last year, it might point to a part time outfit being able to stand toe to toe with a SL side who just missed the top 8.
As far as I can see, 4 Ties in last years 4th round featured a SL side v an opponent from a lower division.....the points scored by the SL side was 200-32 (50-8).....the 5th round saw 3 ties with the result 170-24 (57-8)....then 2 games 81-18 (40-9). Please feel free to define "holding your own"
Greg Florimos Boots wrote:
Like last season Fax played Widnes and the difference between the teams was really only Kevin Brown.
No...the difference was 24 points in a loss 10-34 at home. Everything else is simply opinion......you didn't need to be there to know that one side scored 24 more points than the other.
Greg Florimos Boots wrote:
Well this year if Fax did make the 8 they would have spent nearly 500K more than last season
No matter how much the club spend, there is a finite number of talented players available and a dose of realism would point towards the 14 teams in the UK that are full time professional will have snapped up the best players.....I fully expect London Bradford and Leigh to win 18 games each next year with the 6 games featuring those three sides dictating the placings 1-3.......and I expect some real shallockings to be dished out in the first 23 rounds.....
Greg Florimos Boots wrote:
and would enter that league in good form where as the teams in the bottom 4 in SL will be on a bit of a downer.
The teams who finish 9-12th in SL will not be on anything other than the war-path, defending their SL livelihoods. This is not a Challenge Cup scenario where the plucky underdog will throw everything at the SL side in the hope their better financed opponents have a bad day, but a match against a team who are aware that every point for and against will count.....they will face 3 full time sides and a part time outfit and the part time outfit will be the easybeats of that comp.
Greg Florimos Boots wrote:
I don not think for 1 second that a team from the Championship will get promoted to SL but I also dont expect to see the scorelines mentioned in this thread either.
I believe the teams who finish 9th & 10th in SL will score over 350 points in their 7 games.....I believe 11th placed SL side will score in excess of 300. Happy to be proven wrong, but statistically I would seem to be on the money....The 4th round in 2013 average scores were 54-10......then 64-4 and then 29-10.......so 700-116 over 13 ties.
To recap... over 2013 and 2014 Lower league sides holding their own in 22 CC ties v SL sides resulted in an overall score-line of 1151-190...or 52-9 if you prefer averages......keep chuckling.