Re: Marky Facing a Ban : Sat Jul 01, 2017 1:06 pm  

Red, it may be but it's what we have so we accept it or follow another sport.

Re: Marky Facing a Ban : Sat Jul 01, 2017 1:14 pm  

northernbloke wrote:

What might be worth doing as well is looking at the match review list of referred incidents, have a look as a club what we have had so far this season, and how many resulted in no charge compared to any ban.
It also gives a pretty detailed description of why the decision was made, and interestingly that the only counter evidence given by the club was Hendon by phone not the player in person.

It's a long way to go for a ten minute meeting when the decision has already been made.

Re: Marky Facing a Ban : Sat Jul 01, 2017 3:57 pm  

someone did that on facebook. we had been up before the disciplinary 6 times this season and had two charges. Wigan if I remember correctly were 58 times before the disciplinary and 6 charges oh well I am sure you can turn this to your advantage northernbloke. What is the percentage of charge for london and the percentage for Wigan. Seem to remember Warrington were as high as Wigan and as low in the charge department. maybe the whole thing ought to be analysed by a truly independent panel

Re: Marky Facing a Ban : Sat Jul 01, 2017 7:27 pm  

Having watched this afternoons Catalan Leigh game, my respect for Mr Hewer as a referee is even lower than that of Mr Hicks.

Re: Marky Facing a Ban : Sat Jul 01, 2017 8:00 pm  

Mr hewer ...oh dear oh dear oh dear

Re: Marky Facing a Ban : Sun Jul 02, 2017 10:45 am  

If you take like for like, so instead of looking at Wigan Warrington etc look at other championship teams. Look at KR Dewsbury Oldham Halifax instead.

Then you can choose to look at it two ways glass hall full or half empty.
Half full we have only been in front of the panel 6 times compare that to the other teams most are well into double figures
Half empty out of the 6 2 have resulted in charges. The RFL must hate us, Toulouse have 7 with 3 charges!

Look at any organisation that has discip hearings, look at the countries judiciary that hold hearings. If you get charged with any offence in any situation chances are if you can't be bothered to make the effort to appear before that hearing then the outcome is likely to be worse than if you do appear, it's fact. We hardly ever send the player up to red hall to explain what his thoughts on the action were, so the club does very little to help the panel.

For me I look at the positive, we have only had 6 events referred which has to be a positive.