Re: Catalans v Leeds : Mon Sep 12, 2022 4:05 pm  

ploinerrhino wrote:

This Friday has nothing to do with your ridiculous statement

get back in your box

Re: Catalans v Leeds : Mon Sep 12, 2022 4:10 pm  

ploinerrhino wrote:

This Friday has nothing to do with your ridiculous statement

It’s ridiculous in your opinion, your opinion being that of a Leeds fan. Friday gone would suggest it isn’t that ridiculous after all.

As I say let’s see how we go this week. I doubt your tactics will change much but hopefully we don’t get dragged in to all the niggle.

Re: Catalans v Leeds : Tue Sep 13, 2022 7:00 am  

NickyKiss wrote:

It’s ridiculous in your opinion, your opinion being that of a Leeds fan. Friday gone would suggest it isn’t that ridiculous after all.

As I say let’s see how we go this week. I doubt your tactics will change much but hopefully we don’t get dragged in to all the niggle.

I've sat down and watched Leeds properly twice since Smith came in (against Wigan & Cats) and its clear as day he's got them to push the niggle and aggression in the tackle as part of a strong defensive effort, and both times they've played some decent rugby on the back of it.
For the life of me I can't understand what is controversial or disrespectful about pointing that out?

Re: Catalans v Leeds : Tue Sep 13, 2022 9:16 am  

spartakmixtapes wrote:

I've sat down and watched Leeds properly twice since Smith came in (against Wigan & Cats) and its clear as day he's got them to push the niggle and aggression in the tackle as part of a strong defensive effort, and both times they've played some decent rugby on the back of it.
For the life of me I can't understand what is controversial or disrespectful about pointing that out?

Aye, me neither. I pointed out I do not have an issue with it and it’s all part of the game but it’s clear as day. Look at Cameron Smith last Friday, a guy who I always saw as a bit too nice if anything pre Rohan Smith and on Friday it was niggle after niggle, pushing and shoving at every play the ball and so on.

Re: Catalans v Leeds : Tue Sep 13, 2022 10:02 am  

As a Leeds fan I see it a bit differently (to be expected). 3rd recent game against Catalans and Smith knew to play on their indiscipline and targeted the players most likely to react. He might try the same with yours though given you've looked pretty controlled this year I doubt he'll waste time on a tactic unlikely to work. What he may do is rattle any players unsettled by being roughed up a bit, or direct carries aplenty at players who get gassed easily and so on. Identify weakness and exploit it in other words. Of course Catalans were a fairly low bar; yourselves and the other surviving two have far fewer weaknesses. Gonna be an interesting contest.

Re: Catalans v Leeds : Tue Sep 13, 2022 10:15 am  

Clearwing wrote:

As a Leeds fan I see it a bit differently (to be expected). 3rd recent game against Catalans and Smith knew to play on their indiscipline and targeted the players most likely to react. He might try the same with yours though given you've looked pretty controlled this year I doubt he'll waste time on a tactic unlikely to work. What he may do is rattle any players unsettled by being roughed up a bit, or direct carries aplenty at players who get gassed easily and so on. Identify weakness and exploit it in other words. Of course Catalans were a fairly low bar; yourselves and the other surviving two have far fewer weaknesses. Gonna be an interesting contest.

I don't see how that is seeing it differently TBH, it was clearly a deliberate tactic to try to niggle and wind up Catalans players and it worked?
In that last game against us it was clear Harry Newman had been told to give Field some treatment whenever possible -
Quote - “In every game I pick a battle with someone who can make an influence and it’s been obvious all season that Jai Field has been incredible and in this game I put my hand up and I said I’d do a job on him and I thought I did that. We spoke before that if I could get into him and ruffle him then I might prevent him scoring the tries he does in attack.”
Again, whats the problem with pointing out what your deliberate and pre-planned tactic is? It's all part of the game and you play some decent rugby on the back of it. Its definitely something Wigan will have to deal with on Friday, whats the issue?

Re: Catalans v Leeds : Tue Sep 13, 2022 10:33 am  

Again, its not a criticism, all teams do it to a certain degree, see Wigan's treatment of Welsby in the last Derby.

Re: Catalans v Leeds : Tue Sep 13, 2022 11:03 am  

Clearwing wrote:

As a Leeds fan I see it a bit differently (to be expected). 3rd recent game against Catalans and Smith knew to play on their indiscipline and targeted the players most likely to react. He might try the same with yours though given you've looked pretty controlled this year I doubt he'll waste time on a tactic unlikely to work. What he may do is rattle any players unsettled by being roughed up a bit, or direct carries aplenty at players who get gassed easily and so on. Identify weakness and exploit it in other words. Of course Catalans were a fairly low bar; yourselves and the other surviving two have far fewer weaknesses. Gonna be an interesting contest.

Sounds fair enough to me. I think there will be plenty of niggle both ways because it’s the nature of the beast come play off time. We were miles off in our attitude at your place recently but I’m sure both sides will be on for this. It’s going to be a great game I reckon. Leeds under Rohan Smith feel a bit like Saints right at the start of Holbrooks time, when they had a run and ended up unlucky in losing a semi at Cas via a Luke Gale drop goal. Whatever happens I think next season will be a very good one for Leeds.

Re: Catalans v Leeds : Tue Sep 13, 2022 1:46 pm  

spartakmixtapes wrote:

Again, its not a criticism, all teams do it to a certain degree, see Wigan's treatment of Welsby in the last Derby.

That was payback and the little brat didnt like it one bit

Re: Catalans v Leeds : Tue Sep 13, 2022 3:48 pm  

The Catalan implosion and antics only started after they went 2 scores behind. If they had kept composure they might have had a better chance.
Would imagine they are on a downward spiral. Looking at the players we have missing especially Martin ,it’s a tall order for us to win.
Probably one thing in our favour is we are battle hardened, our last 2 games have been hard. Sometimes it’s not favourable to have a week,off.