Re: Rumours and signings v9 : Wed Feb 05, 2025 1:13 pm  

Mark_P1973 wrote:

i agree but i think it has tended to be more the players have signed for Saints / Wigan having come from a traditional amateur club in the other town. So for example Welsby and Makinson played for Shevvy Sharks and St Judes but signed for Saints and not Wigan, as opposed to signing for Wigan and then moving to Saints

it was interesting and i think its been covered before that we signed so many onto our scholarship level i think it was from Thatto Heath in our last intake

Yeah from the all-conquering Thatto Heath team, Saints signed 3 but Wigan signed 8. Of those 8, 7 are die hard Saints fans. Wigan are now (annoyingly) leading the way with their scouting too. Leigh have started to get their act together, I believe they signed a couple too.

I've no idea what money Vaughan has signed for but ironically he would've had more chance to break into Saints regularly than the current Wigan team. Sironen will undoubtedly go home at the end of the season and Batchelor and Whitley have been poor. Hurrell will undoubtedly go too at the end of the season (hopefully) and Percival is always injured. Vaughan would most likely have started a lot of games in 2026.

Re: Rumours and signings v9 : Wed Feb 05, 2025 1:36 pm  

Stu M wrote:

Really? Because you don't like him as a person or feel he is over-rated?

Great player but there comes a point where someone is so associated with a rival club that I wouldn't want us to go there. Goading the Wigan fans doesn't offend me one bit (in fact good for him) but I wouldn't want to see him in a Wigan shirt now he is essentially the pantomime villain.

Re: Rumours and signings v9 : Wed Feb 05, 2025 3:22 pm  

MadDogg wrote:

Great player but there comes a point where someone is so associated with a rival club that I wouldn't want us to go there. Goading the Wigan fans doesn't offend me one bit (in fact good for him) but I wouldn't want to see him in a Wigan shirt now he is essentially the pantomime villain.

Similar from me, but I also dont think his best years are in front of him and we would only get a few goods years out of him

Re: Rumours and signings v9 : Wed Feb 05, 2025 3:46 pm  

MadDogg wrote:

Great player but there comes a point where someone is so associated with a rival club that I wouldn't want us to go there. Goading the Wigan fans doesn't offend me one bit (in fact good for him) but I wouldn't want to see him in a Wigan shirt now he is essentially the pantomime villain.

Super League would be much better without this kind of tribal thinking. It prevents top players moving around (and improving) other clubs. The NRL has a great market which betters its league every year by spreading around talent.

Re: Rumours and signings v9 : Wed Feb 05, 2025 3:52 pm  

It would almost be like cheering for Sean Long

Re: Rumours and signings v9 : Wed Feb 05, 2025 4:04 pm  

[Gareth] wrote:

It would almost be like cheering for Sean Long

It's not like you're going to be hugging him in the showers after the game. It's just a player for the team you support.

Re: Rumours and signings v9 : Wed Feb 05, 2025 5:02 pm  

Wigg'n wrote:

Super League would be much better without this kind of tribal thinking. It prevents top players moving around (and improving) other clubs. The NRL has a great market which betters its league every year by spreading around talent.

Personally, I think the strength of RL is in its club rivalries. We seem fixated on pushing the "international game" when in reality it isn't half as popular as Wigan vs. Saints or the Hull derby.

The rivalry, and even the animosity, is something we should tap into more. The story around Williams playing against Wigan, Thompson against Saints, etc., makes it either mean more or adds a bit of intrigue to the neutral.

Re: Rumours and signings v9 : Wed Feb 05, 2025 5:56 pm  

TKOR wrote:

Personally, I think the strength of RL is in its club rivalries. We seem fixated on pushing the "international game" when in reality it isn't half as popular as Wigan vs. Saints or the Hull derby.

The rivalry, and even the animosity, is something we should tap into more. The story around Williams playing against Wigan, Thompson against Saints, etc., makes it either mean more or adds a bit of intrigue to the neutral.

I agree with this. I do think Welsby in a Wigan shirt would be fantastic too. He’s a top notch player and can you imagine the response and the build up to the derby game.

I though have a different mindset when it comes to the international game. I cannot stand it when club loyalties cause fans to boo and jeer our English players because of the club they play for.

Re: Rumours and signings v9 : Wed Feb 05, 2025 6:36 pm  

Stu M wrote: This is the issue now with Wigan's financial muscle. There are rumours from everywhere which creates a bit of scare-mongering. Don't get me wrong I'm as bad given that their wealth is worrying for the rest of SL, but there's no way Wigan are signing Welsby, Robertson and Lees. This article suggests that Wigan are looking to recruit this season, mind you I'm not suggesting it is any of those you have named. What we have done though is increased the cost to St Helens or any other teams thinking of recruiting them. The lack of noise surrounding Lees is deafening. I see more information has been release re Knowles future today. https://www.seriousaboutrl.com/wigan-wa ... de-101210/

Stu M wrote: This is the issue now with Wigan's financial muscle. There are rumours from everywhere which creates a bit of scare-mongering. Don't get me wrong I'm as bad given that their wealth is worrying for the rest of SL, but there's no way Wigan are signing Welsby, Robertson and Lees. This article suggests that Wigan are looking to recruit this season, mind you I'm not suggesting it is any of those you have named. What we have done though is increased the cost to St Helens or any other teams thinking of recruiting them. The lack of noise surrounding Lees is deafening. I see more information has been release re Knowles future today. https://www.seriousaboutrl.com/wigan-wa ... de-101210/

Re: Rumours and signings v9 : Wed Feb 05, 2025 6:39 pm  

Stu M wrote:

Really? Because you don't like him as a person or feel he is over-rated?

Over-rated I’m not sure.
Over-the-hill absolutely.