Re: Forward watch : Mon Apr 11, 2022 1:31 pm  

Itchy Arsenal wrote:

Historically the verb decimated meant one in ten. So i could assume, if I use the historical meaning and you have 4 forwards on the bench, that you will have one forward missing.

Not sure of the meaning in today’s context but decimated to me would be a substantial number perhaps even the majority. So you have 4 or 5 missing starting forwards?

Either that or it was a sarcastic comment.

Re: Forward watch : Mon Apr 11, 2022 1:37 pm  

The Yellow Giraffe wrote:

Either that or it was a sarcastic comment.

Or someone’s filling their duds? lol.

Long time since I heard any sarcasm from a Saints fan. You got me there YG.

Young Wingfield will be a perfect forward replacement for you guys.

Your pack is obviously the benchmark but hopefully we will have a good pop on Friday

Re: Forward watch : Mon Apr 11, 2022 1:40 pm  

Itchy Arsenal wrote:

Or someone’s filling their duds? lol.

Long time since I heard any sarcasm from a Saints fan. You got me there YG.

Young Wingfield will be a perfect forward replacement for you guys.

Your pack is obviously the benchmark but hopefully we will have a good pop on Friday

Yeah I assume it'll be Wingfield or Bell to come in, most likely Wingfield. I think the rest of the 17 will be unchanged from the weekend.

I am confident our pack can and will get on top, we are fairly ruthless in that department at the moment. Our vulnerability at the minute is our right edge defence with Hurrell in particular uncomfortable as soon as anyone does anything but run straight at him. I imagine you men will be trying to get Field or French in some space around him as much as possible.

Re: Forward watch : Mon Apr 11, 2022 3:05 pm  

We've looked much better with no Isa IMO. He's a grafter no doubt, but asks no questions of defences whatsoever bar his 1-out 1-up carries. His work off the ball is nowhere near our other back rowers, and he creates not even an inkling of doubt in defences. The Field try off Faz at the weekend is a prime example of giving the halfback the option to pick the right pass - as it turns out it worked the other way here with the defenders following Field, leaving the short ball the best option. Field wrapping around Isa in that situation (albeit it would be on the right-hand edge) rarely would have the same outcome.

Re: Forward watch : Mon Apr 11, 2022 5:41 pm  

NickyKiss wrote:

I don’t think we’ll get them with it being the cup as people pull them from the Superleague site but they would be interesting. I’d imagine they’d be really impressive for Bateman, Farrell and Havard. I thought Shorrocks was superb as well and has really put a case forward to stay in the 17 when guys like Ellis and Isa are back.

That's a shame.

Re. Shorrocks, i think i have mentioned this here before but i rate him highly. I genuinely see him as our future for the loose forward position. I feel he has alot of the attributes to make a good go at it, especially if he gets a run of games there at some point to bed in.

Re: Forward watch : Mon Apr 11, 2022 6:21 pm  

BoredWiganer wrote:

That's a shame.

Re. Shorrocks, i think i have mentioned this here before but i rate him highly. I genuinely see him as our future for the loose forward position. I feel he has alot of the attributes to make a good go at it, especially if he gets a run of games there at some point to bed in.

Only if the second row is bulked in size significantly beyond what we have now.

Re: Forward watch : Mon Apr 11, 2022 6:52 pm  

DannyT wrote:

Only if the second row is bulked in size significantly beyond what we have now.

Fair comment and a good point, although i don't think he has much issue in the defensive department wasn't he top tackler in the whole league last year? He also made good yardage yesterday, granted one example and he isn't the biggest currently. I do think he has put abit of size on this season and still is only 22.

If he can work out there, i see him as our best current option for a ball playing loose.

I will say, failing that or short term, i really like smithies there for his workload and determination. Ellis has also played some NRL games there aswell but that would very much be a 3 "middles" type NRL situation which i am not a fan of and i don't think really suits the style of open play we seem to be aiming for.

Re: Forward watch : Mon Apr 11, 2022 6:55 pm  

ralvag wrote:

We've looked much better with no Isa IMO. He's a grafter no doubt, but asks no questions of defences whatsoever bar his 1-out 1-up carries. His work off the ball is nowhere near our other back rowers, and he creates not even an inkling of doubt in defences. The Field try off Faz at the weekend is a prime example of giving the halfback the option to pick the right pass - as it turns out it worked the other way here with the defenders following Field, leaving the short ball the best option. Field wrapping around Isa in that situation (albeit it would be on the right-hand edge) rarely would have the same outcome.

Fully agree. This season was one season too long at wigan for me. To be fair i said the same about tommy last season and during pre season, he has fully proved me wrong so far so would love isa to do the same! Just don't see how.

Re: Forward watch : Mon Apr 11, 2022 7:21 pm  

He’s been a credit to the club Isa and is clearly a real leader in the group but he has had a poor start to the season. He should have to fight for his place and that should always be the case at a club like Wigan. I’m still convinced there’s a place in the squad for him because we are light on real experience in the pack but if guys like Smithies and Shorrocks go past him, so be it because realistically that’s what you want.

Re: Forward watch : Mon Apr 11, 2022 8:57 pm  

NickyKiss wrote:

He’s been a credit to the club Isa and is clearly a real leader in the group but he has had a poor start to the season. He should have to fight for his place and that should always be the case at a club like Wigan. I’m still convinced there’s a place in the squad for him because we are light on real experience in the pack but if guys like Smithies and Shorrocks go past him, so be it because realistically that’s what you want.

Yes this is always the thing when talking about a players worth to the team, it doesn't start and end on the pitch. You can really see isa being a nice guy in general who is easy to get along with and for the younger players to approach with any questions or for advise.

He is also a real athelete and could see him being the person who sets a benchmark of conduct and effort in training.

These are the sorts of things we may not always see or be aware of as fans, but anybody who has being around that sort of environment knows how critical them type of characters can be for a positive and productive team environment.