Re: The Big Axe : Sun Oct 06, 2019 3:55 pm  

MOUSE13 wrote:

Because of the increased fitness/muscle mass of players these days i would suspect that the collision speed/impacts are harder. Plus with us now living in a blame/claim culture people are more worried about such cliams.
Just a thought.

Nail on head, so to speak.

Re: The Big Axe : Mon Oct 07, 2019 9:06 am  

The Joe Burgess and Clubb re-signings are criminal IMO.

Ever since he said “he’d like another crack at the NRL” we should have been trying to move Burgess on. Shadow of the player he was at 19.

If we lose Davies to Leeds but keep burgess for a year that would be criminal.

Clubb looks finished.

Re: The Big Axe : Mon Oct 07, 2019 11:21 am  

MOUSE13 wrote:

Because of the increased fitness/muscle mass of players these days i would suspect that the collision speed/impacts are harder. Plus with us now living in a blame/claim culture people are more worried about such cliams.
Just a thought.

But we have taken away shoulder charges which were regularly used to knock an opposition player to kingdom come. The game has never been more sterile IMO.

Is it time RL players were forced to wear helmets like the NRL?

Re: The Big Axe : Mon Oct 07, 2019 11:31 am  

The_Enforcer wrote:

But we have taken away shoulder charges which were regularly used to knock an opposition player to kingdom come. The game has never been more sterile IMO.

Is it time RL players were forced to wear helmets like the NRL?

It could well come to helmets in the end..once a lawyer gets a case together than games such as rugby are very much in the firing line,sterile it may be but it’s the future,our blame everyone else culture you have to thank for it too.

Re: The Big Axe : Mon Oct 07, 2019 11:32 am  

The_Enforcer wrote:

MOUSE13 wrote:

Because of the increased fitness/muscle mass of players these days i would suspect that the collision speed/impacts are harder. Plus with us now living in a blame/claim culture people are more worried about such cliams.
Just a thought.

But we have taken away shoulder charges which were regularly used to knock an opposition player to kingdom come. The game has never been more sterile IMO.

Is it time RL players were forced to wear helmets like the NRL?

Not sure if you're a troll or just chatting BS because of 'bro science' syndrome.

If you'd read any of the research on CTE in sport (especially the stuff related to the NFL) then you'd realise the helmets provide no protection from concussions.

Why engage or bring up a topic if you haven't read up on the science behind it?

Re: The Big Axe : Mon Oct 07, 2019 11:46 am  

A player in the NFL (think it was a Raiders player) was banned for the year last week for a helmet to helmet tackle and a QB got knocked out cold last night after another helmet to helmet clash.
Who knows, they might look at getting rid of helmets at this rate.

Re: The Big Axe : Mon Oct 07, 2019 12:06 pm  

apollosghost wrote: A player in the NFL (think it was a Raiders player) was banned for the year last week for a helmet to helmet tackle and a QB got knocked out cold last night after another helmet to helmet clash. Who knows, they might look at getting rid of helmets at this rate. Vontaze Burfict https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=15XcPn1no4k Cracking win last night though, GO RAIDERS!

apollosghost wrote: A player in the NFL (think it was a Raiders player) was banned for the year last week for a helmet to helmet tackle and a QB got knocked out cold last night after another helmet to helmet clash. Who knows, they might look at getting rid of helmets at this rate. Vontaze Burfict https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=15XcPn1no4k Cracking win last night though, GO RAIDERS!

Re: The Big Axe : Mon Oct 07, 2019 4:18 pm  

sergeant pepper wrote:

Not sure if you're a troll or just chatting BS because of 'bro science' syndrome.

If you'd read any of the research on CTE in sport (especially the stuff related to the NFL) then you'd realise the helmets provide no protection from concussions.

Why engage or bring up a topic if you haven't read up on the science behind it?

I am trying to discuss the subject and asking questions. Is that ok or do i need a special license from you and your clique?

At no point have i tried to pretend to be an expert and im pretty sure you are not an expert either.

Re: The Big Axe : Mon Oct 07, 2019 4:22 pm  

hengirl wrote:

It could well come to helmets in the end..once a lawyer gets a case together than games such as rugby are very much in the firing line,sterile it may be but it’s the future,our blame everyone else culture you have to thank for it too.

Well i mean the NRL wear helmets and you have to wear an helmet on a motorbike so i am guessing that they do offer some protection from head injuries. I know i would rather clash heads with somebody with an helmet on rather than no helmet.

Re: The Big Axe : Mon Oct 07, 2019 4:25 pm  

apollosghost wrote:

A player in the NFL (think it was a Raiders player) was banned for the year last week for a helmet to helmet tackle and a QB got knocked out cold last night after another helmet to helmet clash.
Who knows, they might look at getting rid of helmets at this rate.

Perhaps a redesign of the helmets to have soft padding on the outside to cushion the impact?