It’s harsh to judge Smith given the powder puff pack he is playing behind but I really don’t see him as a top half prospect never mind a half capable of playing for a side expected to challenge for honours.
There are bigger issues than that however it’s a situation we need to address.
Generally it’s a bit like watching an amateur kids game where a team of immature 13 year olds turn up to play a mature team of 13 year olds.
Plenty of effort but in reality getting dominated in all aspects of the game.
With the number of injuries we have and the fact we are so inferior to most teams physically our conditioning department needs to be refreshed in a significant way.