Re: ganson : Sat Jul 31, 2010 6:23 pm  

I take it that none of you saw Ganson take J Tomkins aside and list a load of offences, counting them off on his fingers as he did so?

No?
Thought not.

Shortly afterwards, Ganson lost patience and binned poor Coley who was taking the rap for others' repeatedly foul play.

By the way, congrats on a good overall performance.
Good game.

Re: ganson : Sat Jul 31, 2010 6:39 pm  

El Barbudo wrote:

I take it that none of you saw Ganson take J Tomkins aside and list a load of offences, counting them off on his fingers as he did so?

No?
Thought not.

Shortly afterwards, Ganson lost patience and binned poor Coley who was taking the rap for others' repeatedly foul play.

By the way, congrats on a good overall performance.
Good game.

yes I heard that. wigan were on a warning so any more foul play should have resulted in a sinbin. Coley didn't commit a foul so shouldn't have been sinbinned, is that clear enough for you? No? Thought not.

Re: ganson : Sat Jul 31, 2010 6:55 pm  

gpartin wrote:

yes I heard that. wigan were on a warning so any more foul play should have resulted in a sinbin. Coley didn't commit a foul so shouldn't have been sinbinned, is that clear enough for you? No? Thought not.

As it happens, I had noticed, hence my comment about "poor Coley".
If not him, it would have been whoever Ganson thought.

Do we agree that Wigan had reached the limit on foul play?

Re: ganson : Sat Jul 31, 2010 7:01 pm  

El Barbudo wrote:

As it happens, I had noticed, hence my comment about "poor Coley".
If not him, it would have been whoever Ganson thought.

Do we agree that Wigan had reached the limit on foul play?

Yes, but then we didn't commit a foul, and still had someone sin binned.

Re: ganson : Sat Jul 31, 2010 7:04 pm  

El Barbudo wrote:

As it happens, I had noticed, hence my comment about "poor Coley".
If not him, it would have been whoever Ganson thought.

Do we agree that Wigan had reached the limit on foul play?

reached it at the point of getting a warning but didn't go over it at the point Coley was wrongly binned. Hence your sarcy comment about Wigan fans not knowing we were on a warning was totally ridiculous because it doesn't change anything about the wrongness of the decision.

Re: ganson : Sat Jul 31, 2010 7:40 pm  

I feel that its is time referee's like Ganson should be made accountable for their actions. They make far too many errors and seem to be getting away with below par performances week in & week out. Ganson is just a disgrace!!!!

Re: ganson : Sat Jul 31, 2010 7:44 pm  

Was Ganson the video ref tonight ? because whoever it was was about to make a massive booboo before someone had a quick word.

Re: ganson : Sat Jul 31, 2010 7:47 pm  

Ganson doesn't even know the rules of the game, as he was going to disallow Saints try tonight until Clarky enlightened the muppet.

Re: ganson : Sat Jul 31, 2010 7:48 pm  

gpartin wrote:

reached it at the point of getting a warning but didn't go over it at the point Coley was wrongly binned. Hence your sarcy comment about Wigan fans not knowing we were on a warning was totally ridiculous because it doesn't change anything about the wrongness of the decision.

OK, have it your way.
Coley was wrongly binned and that's all there is to it.
Ignore all the misdemeanours your lads got away with for no binnings.
Ignore the fact that your team are 2nd in the penalty count stakes across the whole Super League but, according to posters around here, Leeds are the dirty team.
Blame the refs, all of them.
Blame the RFL.

Even when you win you cling on to your perceived victimhood.

Good luck in the semis ... oh, hang on ...

Re: ganson : Sat Jul 31, 2010 7:55 pm  

El Barbudo wrote:

OK, have it your way.
Coley was wrongly binned and that's all there is to it.
Ignore all the misdemeanours your lads got away with for no binnings.
Ignore the fact that your team are 2nd in the penalty count stakes across the whole Super League but, according to posters around here, Leeds are the dirty team.
Blame the refs, all of them.
Blame the RFL.

Even when you win you cling on to your perceived victimhood.

Good luck in the semis ... oh, hang on ...

Your missing the point, no-ones arguin that we were on a warning, but then Coley DID NOT COMMIT A FOUL and then got sinbinned?! Then later in the game Leeds were also put on a warning after a longer string of penalties than we were.

There is a difference between being dirty and being heavily penalised, with the style of our defence we are going to give away a lot of penalties for holding down and messing around at the PTB, but you don't see our players going in knee up, elbowing people to the face etc etc, thats what dirty means.