Re: Maguire to see out contract : Tue Feb 08, 2011 2:00 pm  

sgtwilko wrote:

No u-turn at all. Just the same thing I've always said. It's my opinion but I think its a fair point. You just dont like it so want to twist it.it's what you always do when you write a novel of a post.

Of course it's speculation, I'm speculating that a coach would take an nrl job over an sl job? Which bit of that have you a problem with! Basically you get all defensive because it's your coach. I would say the same for any sl coach, browny is another one who would going a concrete offer was on the table. But when I offer up an opinion the replies don't discuss the issue they are full of deflections, its because I'm a Leeds fan? Or im envious? I've seen Leeds win 4 titles 3 in a row I have nothing to be bitter about I watched Leeds for long enough win nowt. If they win nowt again al die a happy man. Win or lose I don't love em anymore or any less.

It's got nothing to do with me liking it or not.

You offered Speculative Opinion and claimed it was FACT. You then said we were all mad & delusional if we didn't agree with your opinion.

With regards to me "But when I offer up an opinion the replies don't discuss the issue they are full of deflections" I'm pretty sure I asked what Harlem Globe trotter style rugby had to with wheter MM would or wouldn't accept an NRL Offer if it came along?

As far as I can see nothings changed since page 1 - Nobody knows if MM has been offered a contract and nobody knows if he was offered one whter he would accept it?

Are you sticking by your original statement that he Would definately go and were all Mad & Deluded to think otherwise or not?

Re: Maguire to see out contract : Wed Feb 09, 2011 8:41 am  

Jukesays wrote:

It's got nothing to do with me liking it or not.

You offered Speculative Opinion and claimed it was FACT. You then said we were all mad & delusional if we didn't agree with your opinion.

With regards to me "But when I offer up an opinion the replies don't discuss the issue they are full of deflections" I'm pretty sure I asked what Harlem Globe trotter style rugby had to with wheter MM would or wouldn't accept an NRL Offer if it came along?

As far as I can see nothings changed since page 1 - Nobody knows if MM has been offered a contract and nobody knows if he was offered one whter he would accept it?

Are you sticking by your original statement that he Would definately go and were all Mad & Deluded to think otherwise or not?

To be honest I didn't say fact anywhere but I do think people are deluded if they think a coach would turn down a head coach job in the nrl to stay in sl.

Re: Maguire to see out contract : Wed Feb 09, 2011 8:55 am  

sgtwilko wrote:

To be honest I didn't say fact anywhere but I do think people are deluded if they think a coach would turn down a head coach job in the nrl to stay in sl.

Fair enough, but I'm pretty sure that a majority of people wouldn't agree with you and if questioned "Is it beyond reasonable doubt that ANY COACH in SL would ALWAYS take up ANY HEAD COACHES job in the NRL if offered one whilst not even half way through their current contract" and I'm pretty sure they would say No it's not definate that it would happen.

That's all my point was, And I don't consider myself to be delusional to have that opinion.
Now that's not saying that Maguire "Won't" do it, each person will make his own decision, but that doesn't mean I think it's a foregone conclusion!

Re: Maguire to see out contract : Wed Feb 09, 2011 11:28 am  

Jukesays wrote:

Fair enough, but I'm pretty sure that a majority of people wouldn't agree with you and if questioned "Is it beyond reasonable doubt that ANY COACH in SL would ALWAYS take up ANY HEAD COACHES job in the NRL if offered one whilst not even half way through their current contract" and I'm pretty sure they would say No it's not definate that it would happen.

That's all my point was, And I don't consider myself to be delusional to have that opinion.
Now that's not saying that Maguire "Won't" do it, each person will make his own decision, but that doesn't mean I think it's a foregone conclusion!

Fair do's pal. when you put it like that I think I can meet you halfway.

[Pemps]

Re: Maguire to see out contract : Wed Feb 09, 2011 11:31 am