Re: Eddie and Stevo : Tue Apr 28, 2020 7:24 pm
Barry and Terry are so out of touch it’s not funny, the game has moved on from their days, and the analysis they offer is based on when they played, and it’s not what the game is now. As commentators they are there to explain the game to the viewer, good and bad. Barry’s commentary harks back to when the role of prop was really night club bouncer, And doesn’t offer any insight to what’s happening on the pitch. Terry is a nice guy but how many setasixes do we have to hear in a commentary. If the sport has aspirations beyond beer and skittles we need to present the sport better, Wilkin is articulate and comes over well on TV, Clarke is ok, but needs to stop trying to sound clever and just comment on the game, I get the feeling he is trying to find a role in the team. But why do we have so many commentators? Football has a commentator and a summariser then the studio, we are trying to cram too many “personalities” and it does end up a bit “end of the pier”.
Carney is good as a presenter, I like Jon Wells’s reviews, but that really is it with the team at the moment. So who do we bring in Davies is ok, he understands the basics and comes over well, but is also a recognised face.