Re: NFL Chat 2 : Thu Dec 10, 2009 1:13 am  

Not been on here for a while.I see ST CONROY is still trying to convince people that Rodgers is an elite QB but has he admitted that he was wrong about McDaniels ?

Re: NFL Chat 2 : Thu Dec 10, 2009 6:11 am  

DAR130 wrote:

Not been on here for a while.I see ST CONROY is still trying to convince people that Rodgers is an elite QB but has he admitted that he was wrong about McDaniels ?

A) Rodgers is elite

B) I was wrong about the Broncos. They are better than I though and I've said that. I'm not wrong about McDaniels, whatever the record they get he will always be an idiot for running his franchise QB out of town for a vastly inferior QB who has a rubbish arm.

Re: NFL Chat 2 : Thu Dec 10, 2009 9:33 am  

ST_CONROY wrote:

A) Rodgers is elite

B) I was wrong about the Broncos. They are better than I though and I've said that. I'm not wrong about McDaniels, whatever the record they get he will always be an idiot for running his franchise QB out of town for a vastly inferior QB who has a rubbish arm.

Very good I agree and will be elite but he isn't now, hasnt even won a playoff game.

Re: NFL Chat 2 : Thu Dec 10, 2009 10:12 am  

Bevan Wire wrote:

Very good I agree and will be elite but he isn't now, hasnt even won a playoff game.

Not very good, eliite. Out of interst why do you place Romo above him who IIRC also hasn't won a play-off game? Bearing in mind Rodgers hasn't had the chance to.

Re: NFL Chat 2 : Thu Dec 10, 2009 10:15 am  

ST_CONROY wrote:

Not very good, eliite. Out of interst why do you place Romo above him who IIRC also hasn't won a play-off game? Bearing in mind Rodgers hasn't had the chance to.

Hes led team to division titles and winning records.

Re: NFL Chat 2 : Thu Dec 10, 2009 11:16 am  

Bevan Wire wrote:

Hes led team to division titles and winning records.

Then proceeded to blow it in December/January when the pressure builds.

team records aren't indicative of a better player. Chris Johnson at the Titans is the main reason they are improving and have a decent record. Similarly with Rodgers last year, without him we would have a significantly worse record. He can't be punished because he had a worse team around him than the other guys have.

When we win it this year i'm sure that still wouldn't be enough for him to be considered elite.

Re: NFL Chat 2 : Thu Dec 10, 2009 11:24 am  

ST_CONROY wrote:

Then proceeded to blow it in December/January when the pressure builds.

team records aren't indicative of a better player. Chris Johnson at the Titans is the main reason they are improving and have a decent record. Similarly with Rodgers last year, without him we would have a significantly worse record. He can't be punished because he had a worse team around him than the other guys have.

When we win it this year i'm sure that still wouldn't be enough for him to be considered elite.

The team he had had just been to a conference championship game?

Re: NFL Chat 2 : Thu Dec 10, 2009 11:33 am  

Bevan Wire wrote:

The team he had had just been to a conference championship game?

They have been terrible though this year.

Going from a top defence to poor. No pressure on QB's and are 32nd (possibly 31st) against the pass.

LeDale White not being used as much.

Re: NFL Chat 2 : Thu Dec 10, 2009 11:44 am  

I shocked myself at how bad I was at this last week! Ah well, lets give it a whirl

Date & Time Favorite Spread Underdog
Cleveland
Indianapolis
Minnesota
NY Jets
Kansas City
Green Bay
New Orleans
Baltimore
Miami
Carolina
Houston
Tennessee
Washington
San Diego
Philadelphia

Monday Night Football Point Spread

Arizona

Re: NFL Chat 2 : Thu Dec 10, 2009 11:56 am  

ST_CONROY wrote:

They have been terrible though this year.

Going from a top defence to poor. No pressure on QB's and are 32nd (possibly 31st) against the pass.

LeDale White not being used as much.

I was referring to Rodgers having inherited a team that had been to a conf champ.