: Mon Sep 28, 2009 11:26 pm
PAUL M wrote:
It also seems quite harsh on Carrick to me as he was excellent last season but at least we have competition for place which we will need as the season progresses.
Aye I know. Hopefully, he bucks his ideas up because his passing will be vital in the latter end of the season / Champions League.
PAUL M wrote:
Carrick will be itching for his shot with it being WC year.
You would've thought so, this is what makes his poor form / training seem very odd.
PAUL M wrote:
Hargreaves would get the Fletcher role ideally but there is no way he will displace Fletcher on present form. He could possibly play rightback?
Before his injury I seem to remember Hargreaves playing RB and RM, IIRC he was particularly effective on RM, getting passed defenders and getting a decent ball in. For me though, he has to play in CM, he's an excellent tackler and distributer. There is no real reason why he and Fletcher couldn't work together in the middle, but only time will tell.
PAUL M wrote:
It's a shame we don't have the same competition for wingspots, Valencia and Nani are both failing to impress for me.
The Stoke game apart, I actually think Nani has had a decent start to the season. His main problem is his poor distribution and crossing. Sometimes his thinking is off too, as he often makes the wrong decision, see some of his shooting on Saturday for example.
His biggest problem is that he is living in Ronaldo's shadow. There is a fairly good blog on the Beeb website saying that if he concentrated more on his own game and listened to Giggs on crossing / decision making etc instead of trying to mimmick Ronaldo it would make him a better player, I agree totally.
I actually think Valencia is a pretty decent player and will only get better. When him and Giggs are on the field we look like we can string a decent attack down both wings. Valencia has the ability to take men on and get a decent ball in. Apart from them two and Nani though we only have Tosic and Park.
IMO Park has been poor for a while now, and doesn't really offer much. He had two very very good chances versus City to either put us in front / stretch our lead, and both times he wasted it. We certainly looked much better when he went off. I've not seen any of our Reserve games this season so I have no idea how Tosic is getting on, I would like to see him get a few games this year.