The great Cougar winger debate : Sun May 27, 2012 10:47 pm  

Whilst attending games the most often talked about point I come across as regards team selection is who do we play out wide?

So I thought I'd throw it open on here.

I think we've 3 decent wingers all with different qualities. There's Tadulala's experience and know how, Duffy being the local hero who never gives less than 125% and Barnett's pure athleticism.

So let's see what everyone thinks, who would you prefer to play on the wings and why?

Re: The great Cougar winger debate : Mon May 28, 2012 6:10 am  

Both Barnett & Tadulala played pretty well at York.
Pick the best 17 (inc wings) available for each match (based on fitness, form, attitude).

Re: The great Cougar winger debate : Mon May 28, 2012 5:49 pm  

For me it's Semi and Richie. Whilst I agree that Duffy gives 110% in every game and is a local product, I just don't believe he's big enough for this level. IMO our backs are the weakest part of our squad given the 2 mid season departures and it's a shame we missed out on Henderson. I'm just concerned should we get one or two injuries it would leave us a little short. I understand there may be some good kids coming through though.

Re: The great Cougar winger debate : Mon May 28, 2012 11:47 pm  

Richie Barnett and Semi Tadulala

Re: The great Cougar winger debate : Tue May 29, 2012 1:18 am  

Picking with my heart I would never leave Gav out because of his 110% effort always.

Picking with my head it is Semi and Richie.

It says a lot about our quality of our wingers if a player of Gav's quality is not 1st choice.

Re: The great Cougar winger debate : Tue May 29, 2012 10:26 pm  

Semi and Richie

although another combo I think is good

Semi in the centre with Moss on the wing and Haythornthwaite at fully