Re: Keegan Hirst : Thu May 31, 2018 10:16 am  

Adam_Harrison9 wrote:

Is he? Maybe he was a couple of years ago but I'm not seeing it.

He's never produced his peak Cas form since leaving them and signing for Shudds. He has appeared to pile on the weight.

I would still put him light years in front of Nick Scruton though and do prefer him on the pitch for us before Hirst. Still far more positives then negatives for me.

Re: Keegan Hirst : Thu May 31, 2018 12:35 pm  

Adam_Harrison9 wrote:

Is he? Maybe he was a couple of years ago but I'm not seeing it.

When Huby starts he's a different player to the one that comes off the bench.
Had a ropey start last season but once he got his fitness back and got into a rhythm he was quality, too many coaches go with the 'have to rotate my props after 20 minutes'. Huby isn't one of these.
Would you rather start with Huby or Fifita?

Re: Keegan Hirst : Thu May 31, 2018 4:18 pm  

On a like for like comparison with 2016 I think we're much better off with Huby & Hirst than we were with Scruton & Anderson.

Hirst is doing a solid enough job currently, question whether he will develop much further but he has improved since he arrived.