Re: Surprising players : Sat Oct 08, 2022 4:31 pm
PopTart wrote:
If Fifita makes more average metres than mist other props ( certainly more than ours) why does it matter if he doesn't run straight. Only a fool runs straight at defenders if you can run at gaps.
But he's a one off so I agree you can't swap like for like.
And as said, Whitbread isn't a bad comparison to Stosic, but Battye isn't the same quality at all.
But he's a one off so I agree you can't swap like for like.
And as said, Whitbread isn't a bad comparison to Stosic, but Battye isn't the same quality at all.
Jeez I knew you’d do this. It doesn’t matter really but no player is perfect. If you actually listen to the Fifita podcast he stated this himself and that he can’t help himself and he wished he could but his centres instinct never left him.
What it did was push him out wider on being tackled than he intended as he was naturally off balance on occasions.
Why is is it such an issue to talk about players failings. The nearest I Evers saw to a perfect player was Hanley and they are once in a generation.
I never said Battye up to Stocics standard but he plays for us and both Fifita and Stosic don’t. I actuallysaid he could be effective if he stuck to just propping.
Not sure why the sudden petty pedantry, but it might be worth reading what I actually put, still if it makes you happy knock yourself out. Not generally your style all the same.