Will this Bankrupt Rugby League : Sat Oct 08, 2022 9:05 pm  

I can’t think of any Insurance company wanting to insure RL players at any level in the http://e.leeds-live.co.uk/_act/link.php ... Id=7549699

I can’t think of any Insurance company wanting to insure RL players at any level in the http://e.leeds-live.co.uk/_act/link.php ... Id=7549699

Re: Will this Bankrupt Rugby League : Sat Oct 08, 2022 9:14 pm  

This issue for me is the sport just not have that sort of money, it can't cover such a loss therefore the players will be unlikely to get the compo they are chasing.

Re: Will this Bankrupt Rugby League : Sat Oct 08, 2022 9:41 pm  

The protocol for head knocks now are miles apart from the 90's.
John Atkinson at Leeds had dementia and he played on the wing, was that due to playing rugby?
I know Jeff Astle's dementia was blamed on him heading the ball at football, will football be flooded with compensation claims?

[PopTart]

Re: Will this Bankrupt Rugby League : Sat Oct 08, 2022 10:02 pm  

This isn't just League. Other sports are facing this too.

I feel for the players who have suffered but this won't get them what they want.

The crux of the case is whether someone was negligent. That's quite hard to prove mainly because no-one knew the effects of head injuries back then. That's why the protocols are in place now. Even when the player wants to play.

The question is, when did we know, and when were the protocols changed.

Also, we are in a funny position. Lawyers will probably want to target smaller sports like us as we can't defend so easily but if they win they can use it as precedent against RFU and NFL etc.
But that also probably helps us as they won't want that to happen either.

Clearly my legal knowledge is based on watching Suits and Bull but I think that makes me pretty much an expert doesn't it?

Re: Will this Bankrupt Rugby League : Sun Oct 09, 2022 7:13 am  

PopTart wrote:

This isn't just League. Other sports are facing this too.

I feel for the players who have suffered but this won't get them what they want.

The crux of the case is whether someone was negligent. That's quite hard to prove mainly because no-one knew the effects of head injuries back then. That's why the protocols are in place now. Even when the player wants to play.

The question is, when did we know, and when were the protocols changed.

Also, we are in a funny position. Lawyers will probably want to target smaller sports like us as we can't defend so easily but if they win they can use it as precedent against RFU and NFL etc.
But that also probably helps us as they won't want that to happen either
Clearly my legal knowledge is based on watching Suits and Bull but I think that makes me pretty much an expert doesn't it?

Sadly I know a few people who now have, or have died with dementia. I know these people have never played contact sports in their adult life. It might be very difficult for someone to prove playing Rugby League is the cause of their Dementia. As you say, the only winners will be the lawyers.

Re: Will this Bankrupt Rugby League : Sun Oct 09, 2022 7:42 am  

Dunkirk Spirit wrote:

Sadly I know a few people who now have, or have died with dementia. I know these people have never played contact sports in their adult life. It might be very difficult for someone to prove playing Rugby League is the cause of their Dementia. As you say, the only winners will be the lawyers.

Lost mum and 4 of her sisters with dementia, brother-in-law at a young age with it also, he never played any sports. As you say will be difficult to prove.

Re: Will this Bankrupt Rugby League : Sun Oct 09, 2022 11:05 am  

Getting smashed every week cand be good for the brain.
However, is this the cause of dementia and if so, why doesn't every player suffer and why do so many people suffer with dementia, and they've never touched a rugby ball, football, american football etc, etc.

Having said that this issue is huge and will be driven, largely, by what happens in the States.

IF liability was proven against any sport, it could kill all contact sports or lead to players signing some kind of disclaimer.

Re: Will this Bankrupt Rugby League : Sun Oct 09, 2022 11:22 am  

With league and Union players going down the court route this could eventually be a stepping stone for some sort of hybrid game, other than that players will have to sign there rights away to claims.

[PopTart]

Re: Will this Bankrupt Rugby League : Sun Oct 09, 2022 12:23 pm  

MOPSEY LIVES ON wrote:

With league and Union players going down the court route this could eventually be a stepping stone for some sort of hybrid game, other than that players will have to sign there rights away to claims.

Why on earth does this have any link to a hybrid game?

You might as well say we'll make a hybrid game with football and NFL.

[PopTart]

Re: Will this Bankrupt Rugby League : Sun Oct 09, 2022 12:26 pm  

wrencat1873 wrote:

Getting smashed every week cand be good for the brain.
However, is this the cause of dementia and if so, why doesn't every player suffer and why do so many people suffer with dementia, and they've never touched a rugby ball, football, american football etc, etc.

Having said that this issue is huge and will be driven, largely, by what happens in the States.

IF liability was proven against any sport, it could kill all contact sports or lead to players signing some kind of disclaimer.

I think the disclaimer is most likely. Boxing and NRL are massive money earners for people who would have nothing in the normal world. They will never stop people playing.