Full Back : Sun Feb 26, 2023 8:09 pm  

A key position and with Jowitt possibly out injured for a number of weeks who do you think it should be?

Gaskell? Hall? Butterworth?

Or do Trinity try to address the deficiency of depth in a specialist position by bringing in an experienced full back?

A good full back has a big influence on the defensive structures I’m led to believe…. Shaul from Hull? James Clare who doesn’t have a club?

Re: Full Back : Sun Feb 26, 2023 8:21 pm  

Hall would be my choice, Butterworth is nothing more than a reserves player

Re: Full Back : Sun Feb 26, 2023 8:30 pm  

The Avenger wrote:

Hall would be my choice, Butterworth is nothing more than a reserves player

Hall isn’t a full back and neither is Gaskell.

Butterworth is the most experienced full back after Jowitt.

A loan move would be sensible.

Re: Full Back : Sun Feb 26, 2023 8:38 pm  

Trojan Horse wrote:

Hall isn’t a full back and neither is Gaskell.

Butterworth is the most experienced full back after Jowitt.

A loan move would be sensible.

Keeping saying this doesn’t make it true. As i said yesterday his experience at fullback is VERY limited and what he has is against kids. Chucking him in out
Of position risks ruining him. Gaskell actually is our most experienced fullback after Jowitt but he just isn’t very good. Sadly he is the likely option given our lack of funds and lack of availability of loan options.

Re: Full Back : Sun Feb 26, 2023 8:40 pm  

Whoever pulled the plug on the Shaul deal should stay away from future recruitment.

Re: Full Back : Sun Feb 26, 2023 8:42 pm  

asmadasa wrote:

A key position and with Jowitt possibly out injured for a number of weeks who do you think it should be?

Gaskell? Hall? Butterworth?

Or do Trinity try to address the deficiency of depth in a specialist position by bringing in an experienced full back?

A good full back has a big influence on the defensive structures I’m led to believe…. Shaul from Hull? James Clare who doesn’t have a club?

Shaul is currently injured i believe and has started his testimonial season so would be unlikely to come. Clare has given up full time rugby to take up a teaching role and run his kids coaching business. Struggling to think of another fullback who would be available.

Re: Full Back : Sun Feb 26, 2023 8:55 pm  

Shaul has a minor calf strain according to the Hull press release 2 weeks ago but as you say it’s his testimonial year and OOC at the end of this season…

Re: Full Back : Sun Feb 26, 2023 8:58 pm  

Think we could start 3 or 4 new topics on different positions e.g. Stand off, hooker and a few more .I would be knocking on Wigans door to see if we could get Hampshire back to play, Please do not to on about is tackling after the way Gaskell is performing .If we had not let him go ,with the squad we got now he would be a star ..

Re: Full Back : Sun Feb 26, 2023 9:05 pm  

Sacred Cow wrote:

Keeping saying this doesn’t make it true. As i said yesterday his experience at fullback is VERY limited and what he has is against kids. Chucking him in out
Of position risks ruining him. Gaskell actually is our most experienced fullback after Jowitt but he just isn’t very good. Sadly he is the likely option given our lack of funds and lack of availability of loan options.

Well I’ve seen him play there in academy and friendly and I’m pretty sure reserves too last year which isn’t all against kids. All young players are somewhat of a gamble but you never truly know until they get the opportunity.

I don’t think Butterworth is ready but he may very well be a better option than Gaskell. I don’t see an issue with the odd game but it’s overexposure that needs to be avoided.

If it’s 2 month though as rumoured then we need to bring a full back in or we will find it difficult.

I’m not sure who’s available though:

Shaul
Hampshire (probably still injured)
Escare

Re: Full Back : Sun Feb 26, 2023 9:07 pm  

Trojan Horse wrote:

Well I’ve seen him play there in academy and friendly and I’m pretty sure reserves too last year which isn’t all against kids. All young players are somewhat of a gamble but you never truly know until they get the opportunity.

I don’t think Butterworth is ready but he may very well be a better option than Gaskell. I don’t see an issue with the odd game but it’s overexposure that needs to be avoided.

If it’s 2 month though as rumoured then we need to bring a full back in or we will find it difficult.

I’m not sure who’s available though:

Shaul
Hampshire (probably still injured)
Escare

Escaré has signed for Carcassonne. I looked earlier.