[PopTart]

Re: Chester must go now : Mon Aug 31, 2020 7:57 am  

MOPSEY LIVES ON wrote:

I could 100 per cent coach our and any other team better than chester, carter should pull the trigger now and he can take himself with him if he wants.

LOL. I might even give you the coaching thing. You clearly have a good rep from how people talk about you....... But Carter leaving would mean you had no team to coach pretty quickly.

Re: Chester must go now : Mon Aug 31, 2020 8:20 am  

upthecats wrote:

Yes I’d stick as we are...don’t see how many other coaches would do much better without bringing in changes to the team...a bit like Agar at Leeds... initially went there and were no real improvements but then went out and signed Lui, Gale, Martin etc...don’t see us affording that luxury to any potential new coach?

I know Hull had a decent win today but after getting rid of Radford they still shipped in over 50 against Salford so jury still out on that one...

Likewise in the NRL Brisbane got shut of their coach after an horrific season only to get another hammering.

Even the Chester outers must admit he’s having some horrific luck!

To be without 8 backs pre game and lose another two in it...to lose Pitts and Fifita to things totally out of his control and have to play Warrington on their home patch...a game no coach in the world past or present would have coached us to win!

The voice of reason

Re: Chester must go now : Mon Aug 31, 2020 8:37 am  

Egg Banjo wrote:
If I performed as poorly at work as Chester and the players are, I'd be embarrassed at myself and my boss would be having a word with me.

I expected us to lose, and I expected us to be nilled, but that's because I can see that Chester has completely lost it and the players aren't interested in working for him or themselves any more


Just out of interest what is your job?

He’s a professional moaner, and a very good one. Comes out of the woodwork whenever the club has a bad patch, has no perception of support and loyalty. In other words, “a waste of spacel”

Re: Chester must go now : Mon Aug 31, 2020 8:50 am  

Yeah, notice there was no reply...because it’s the biggest load of rubbish argument going is that...if I did the same in my job I’d get sacked...what a load of nonsense!

It’s ok for anyone in any different job to go and do their job when everything is good and all your tools are in tact, you can go and do the job well.

Just say as an example you work in a warehouse...

You’ve a team of 20 workers and you have 5,000 orders to complete on shift.

First three days of the week all is good and you hit your targets.

4th day...4 people ring in sick, two of the four fork lift trucks that have been fine for the first three days stop working so you can only use two...you’re already 4 people down and an hour into the shift there’s an accident and one of the workers has to be taken to hospital, so you’re another two staff down.

Next thing there’s a problem with the computers and orders aren’t coming off like they should be...

Boss calls you in at the end of the shift...right you’ve only managed 2.500 orders this shift you’re sacked...

Re: Chester must go now : Mon Aug 31, 2020 8:56 am  

Lol we're are our 8 Super League backs meaning backs who can come in and old a place down .I will tell you 2 rest have been brought in as panic buys.Fact H K R ad load of injury as lock down started yesterday they had near enough a full team out ,played better rugby than we can.Says a lot about there coaching and conditioner. Think 4 wins,or is it 5 in 27 games and blaming injury is a poor excuse for panic buying of past it S L player's .No point in blaming Mr Carter he as saved the club but is been taken in by poor coaches with plenty of excuses

[PopTart]

Re: Chester must go now : Mon Aug 31, 2020 9:04 am  

alegend wrote:

Lol we're are our 8 Super League backs meaning backs who can come in and old a place down .I will tell you 2 rest have been brought in as panic buys.Fact H K R ad load of injury as lock down started yesterday they had near enough a full team out ,played better rugby than we can.Says a lot about there coaching and conditioner. Think 4 wins,or is it 5 in 27 games and blaming injury is a poor excuse for panic buying of past it S L player's .No point in blaming Mr Carter he as saved the club but is been taken in by poor coaches with plenty of excuses

Injuries are an exact excuse. I can't see how you can say otherwise.
If we don't have our best players on the field we won't do as well as if they were.

Re: Chester must go now : Mon Aug 31, 2020 9:06 am  

alegend wrote:

Lol we're are our 8 Super League backs meaning backs who can come in and old a place down .I will tell you 2 rest have been brought in as panic buys.Fact H K R ad load of injury as lock down started yesterday they had near enough a full team out ,played better rugby than we can.Says a lot about there coaching and conditioner. Think 4 wins,or is it 5 in 27 games and blaming injury is a poor excuse for panic buying of past it S L player's .No point in blaming Mr Carter he as saved the club but is been taken in by poor coaches with plenty of excuses

Yes but previous to that Hull KR lost 40-10 to Warrington at a neutral ground...you bigging them up for that too?

Re: Chester must go now : Mon Aug 31, 2020 9:23 am  

I wouldn't say its Chester out as of yet, we are clearly doing it tough at the moment with some key personnel missing. Yesterday our so called first choice 1,2,3,4,5,7,8 were missing which is going to affect any team.

Yes our confidence is clearly low and we are lacking some leadership on the field which makes the Fifita issue all the more frustrating.

Once we are back to full strength, I'll pass judgement again and if we are in the same position then it might be the time to look at the management

[PopTart]

Re: Chester must go now : Mon Aug 31, 2020 9:30 am  

PopTart wrote:

Injuries are an exact excuse. I can't see how you can say otherwise.
If we don't have our best players on the field we won't do as well as if they were.

We beat Warrington before lockdown

They didn't have Hill or Hughes but had BMM.
Certainly they were near full strength in both games with their marquee players in place.

We had Johnstone, Arundal, Lyne, Kopczak, Tangata playing
And we were at home.

Chester was there in both games.

So why the change in fortune? Could it be Covid, injuries fitness? Or could it be Chester just became a bad coach and should be sacked?

Re: Chester must go now : Mon Aug 31, 2020 9:32 am  

Hull KR are probably a good side to compare against because their results aren’t too dissimilar to outs over the same period.

They have the odd good wins...the close defeats against top sides mixed in with the odd hammerings. In that time frame we’ve played them twice...comprehensively beating them 38–10 on their own patch in a huge pressure game at the back end of last season and losing first game of this season at theirs.

What we saying about their coach then?

Went to Leeds and won them their first title in over 30 years.

Went to Warrington and gave them their first final victory in over 40 years.

Won grand finals, challenge cups, world club challenges, been coach of the year, coached Great Britain.

Has he all of a sudden become a useless coach, or like Chester, is he finding it difficult to get results with limited resources and continually up against it with injuries?