Re: Huddersfield up next : Wed Aug 31, 2022 3:07 pm  

FIL wrote:

Don't remember Shaul dropping any high balls ??

Try the HullKR game. He dropped all those he got to and bottled out of most.

Re: Huddersfield up next : Wed Aug 31, 2022 3:09 pm  

Trojan Horse wrote:

Bizarre to try Shaul in halves I know. Max also is an out and out full back and in an emergency can cover 6 but Max isn’t a 6. That experiment in reserves and first team yielded little results.

I think Max has been very good last few games at full back and he seems to be putting Murphy into some real space too creating the extra man.

The answer to me is simple. We have two halfbacks in Miller/Lino and we pick a full back from Shaul/Jowitt. For me I’d go with Jowitt but if he needs a rest just bang Shaul in.

You don't sign Shaul as a reserve even if you have an unlimited budget. If he signs the message to Max is that he is not required. Continue with Max and spend money where it is required.

Re: Huddersfield up next : Wed Aug 31, 2022 3:11 pm  

Tradition insists I'll be missing this one.

[PopTart]

Re: Huddersfield up next : Wed Aug 31, 2022 3:16 pm  

FSW wrote:

You don't sign Shaul as a reserve even if you have an unlimited budget. If he signs the message to Max is that he is not required. Continue with Max and spend money where it is required.

The message to Max is you have competition so be your best.
Anyone that gives in because they have competition shouldn't be playing professional sport. I'm sure Max knows that.

Re: Huddersfield up next : Wed Aug 31, 2022 3:40 pm  

FSW wrote:

You don't sign Shaul as a reserve even if you have an unlimited budget. If he signs the message to Max is that he is not required. Continue with Max and spend money where it is required.

I wouldn’t sign Shaul. I was purely on about the Hudds game.

Personally I’d sign Jack Broadbent who seems to be going well at Fev and can cover FB and Centre and is only 21. Max would continue to start and develop further.

We must invest in the right areas and for me we have full back covered with an already good option who will continue to improve.

Re: Huddersfield up next : Wed Aug 31, 2022 4:11 pm  

Trojan Horse wrote:

FSW wrote:

You don't sign Shaul as a reserve even if you have an unlimited budget. If he signs the message to Max is that he is not required. Continue with Max and spend money where it is required.

I wouldn’t sign Shaul. I was purely on about the Hudds game.

Personally I’d sign Jack Broadbent who seems to be going well at Fev and can cover FB and Centre and is only 21. Max would continue to start and develop further.

We must invest in the right areas and for me we have full back covered with an already good option who will continue to improve.

Hasn't Broadbent signed for Cas from next season?

Re: Huddersfield up next : Wed Aug 31, 2022 4:27 pm  

PopTart wrote:

The message to Max is you have competition so be your best.
Anyone that gives in because they have competition shouldn't be playing professional sport. I'm sure Max knows that.

Correct. Bizzare logic on here at times.

Re: Huddersfield up next : Wed Aug 31, 2022 4:28 pm  

Trojan Horse wrote:

I wouldn’t sign Shaul. I was purely on about the Hudds game.

Personally I’d sign Jack Broadbent who seems to be going well at Fev and can cover FB and Centre and is only 21. Max would continue to start and develop further.

We must invest in the right areas and for me we have full back covered with an already good option who will continue to improve.

I we are covering FB I do like that Ashalt-Bolt and I assume he's a free agent.

Re: Huddersfield up next : Wed Aug 31, 2022 4:41 pm  

Prince Buster wrote:

F.F.S just look who the ref is on Friday night, what a suprise!

How is it possible that every time we play Huddersfield we get landed with an ex Huddersfield Academy player as referee??

If it wasn't last game of the season I'd probably give it a miss even though I've already got a ticket. Kendall does not know how to be fair when he is refereeing us against Huddersfield. It's a flipping joke!!!!

Re: Huddersfield up next : Wed Aug 31, 2022 5:51 pm  

Fordy wrote:

How is it possible that every time we play Huddersfield we get landed with an ex Huddersfield Academy player as referee??

If it wasn't last game of the season I'd probably give it a miss even though I've already got a ticket. Kendall does not know how to be fair when he is refereeing us against Huddersfield. It's a flipping joke!!!!

Exactly ! Plus huddersfield lad and supporter . It seems to happen far too often. Then compare that to Thaler a ref who for some reason we never get.
I hate giving my money to them, but like you i thought last game etc , but highly unlikely i will be going now