Re: Wakefield Trinity Vs Catalan Dragons : Wed Feb 15, 2023 8:08 pm  

Luppylad wrote:

Why are we taking the clubs best centre and wanting to play him in the pack i dont understand it keep our best players in there best postions will surely be best.hall and langi in centres for me.the only issue is the wings who misses out in lineham,murphy or jorge

Max
Murphy
Hall
Langi
Jorge- gets the nod due to catalan been a pyhsical side
Gaskell
Lino
Battye
Smith
Whitbread
Ashurst
Pitts
Proctor

Antoni
Kaye
Eseh
Butler/kelepi

Who says Langi is the clubs best centre, that’s your opinion not a fact. Now he may well prove to be the best we’ve got but at this moment in time Lynne and Hall have proven to be one of our best centre pairings for years, maybe as far back as Domic & Atkins/Demetriou

Re: Wakefield Trinity Vs Catalan Dragons : Wed Feb 15, 2023 9:01 pm  

The Avenger wrote:

Who says Langi is the clubs best centre, that’s your opinion not a fact. Now he may well prove to be the best we’ve got but at this moment in time Lynne and Hall have proven to be one of our best centre pairings for years, maybe as far back as Domic & Atkins/Demetriou

That's quite a statement considering they've played just 13 games together, and only won five of those.

Re: Wakefield Trinity Vs Catalan Dragons : Wed Feb 15, 2023 9:20 pm  

The Avenger wrote:

Who says Langi is the clubs best centre, that’s your opinion not a fact. Now he may well prove to be the best we’ve got but at this moment in time Lynne and Hall have proven to be one of our best centre pairings for years, maybe as far back as Domic & Atkins/Demetriou

Really lynne and hall best centre pairing in years they hardly ever played together i can only think you had a brain fart and thinking of lynne and topou or you think that hall and lynne where better than those too,as you say we are all entitled to our opinions. As for langi he was when fit he has been a regular starter for arguably one of best teams in the comp somthing lynne and hall havent,i like both hall and lynne and its good to have 3 top centres and yes in my opinion langi is the best

Re: Wakefield Trinity Vs Catalan Dragons : Wed Feb 15, 2023 10:25 pm  

Luppylad wrote:

Really lynne and hall best centre pairing in years they hardly ever played together i can only think you had a brain fart and thinking of lynne and topou or you think that hall and lynne where better than those too,as you say we are all entitled to our opinions. As for langi he was when fit he has been a regular starter for arguably one of best teams in the comp somthing lynne and hall havent,i like both hall and lynne and its good to have 3 top centres and yes in my opinion langi is the best

I like Lyne but I was disappointed with him in 2022. Thought he wasn’t up to his usual good standard.

It’s a new season and hopefully he finds his form again.

Re: Wakefield Trinity Vs Catalan Dragons : Thu Feb 16, 2023 1:07 pm  

Trojan Horse wrote:

I like Lyne but I was disappointed with him in 2022. Thought he wasn’t up to his usual good standard.

It’s a new season and hopefully he finds his form again.

Hate to say it, as I think he's a top player and bloke, but Reece misses out for me.....

Re: Wakefield Trinity Vs Catalan Dragons : Thu Feb 16, 2023 1:15 pm  

BarnsleyGull wrote:

Hate to say it, as I think he's a top player and bloke, but Reece misses out for me.....

Yeah I’ve been leaning towards Langi and Hall. Lyne is still a solid option but it’s a shame 2022 wasn’t a great year for him on field. Who knows though, he could very will pick up some form. He’s certainly got the ability to perform at a good standard in SL for a while yet.

Re: Wakefield Trinity Vs Catalan Dragons : Thu Feb 16, 2023 1:22 pm  

Luppylad wrote:

Really lynne and hall best centre pairing in years they hardly ever played together i can only think you had a brain fart and thinking of lynne and topou or you think that hall and lynne where better than those too,as you say we are all entitled to our opinions. As for langi he was when fit he has been a regular starter for arguably one of best teams in the comp somthing lynne and hall havent,i like both hall and lynne and its good to have 3 top centres and yes in my opinion langi is the best

Toupou wasn’t a centre, he had none of the subtle skills that classic centres need to possess. He was a handful physically but didn’t know how to position his opposite number to get on his outside, he knew nothing of how to attract an oppositions winger to him to create space on the outside for his own winger and even if he did he had no passing game. He was effective only as a physical threat and he only had that for a short number of games in one of his seasons with us.

It doesn’t take a genius to see that both Lynne and Hall are genuine centres and therefore a better centre pairing than Lynne and Toupou. We haven’t had two genuinely high standard proper centres since Domic/Atkins/Demetriou so NO I haven’t had a “brain fart” I’m just better than you at judging players

Re: Wakefield Trinity Vs Catalan Dragons : Thu Feb 16, 2023 1:41 pm  

The Avenger wrote:

Toupou wasn’t a centre, he had none of the subtle skills that classic centres need to possess. He was a handful physically but didn’t know how to position his opposite number to get on his outside, he knew nothing of how to attract an oppositions winger to him to create space on the outside for his own winger and even if he did he had no passing game. He was effective only as a physical threat and he only had that for a short number of games in one of his seasons with us.

It doesn’t take a genius to see that both Lynne and Hall are genuine centres and therefore a better centre pairing than Lynne and Toupou. We haven’t had two genuinely high standard proper centres since Domic/Atkins/Demetriou so NO I haven’t had a “brain fart” I’m just better than you at judging players

Wasn't Tupou named in the SL Dream Team? And his winger got in the same year as well? Surely that makes him a pretty good centre?

Re: Wakefield Trinity Vs Catalan Dragons : Thu Feb 16, 2023 1:42 pm  

Trojan Horse wrote:

Yeah I’ve been leaning towards Langi and Hall. Lyne is still a solid option but it’s a shame 2022 wasn’t a great year for him on field. Who knows though, he could very will pick up some form. He’s certainly got the ability to perform at a good standard in SL for a while yet.

Langi and Lyne to start. Hall on the bench.

[PopTart]

Re: Wakefield Trinity Vs Catalan Dragons : Thu Feb 16, 2023 1:46 pm  

The Avenger wrote:

Toupou wasn’t a centre, he had none of the subtle skills that classic centres need to possess. He was a handful physically but didn’t know how to position his opposite number to get on his outside, he knew nothing of how to attract an oppositions winger to him to create space on the outside for his own winger and even if he did he had no passing game. He was effective only as a physical threat and he only had that for a short number of games in one of his seasons with us.

It doesn’t take a genius to see that both Lynne and Hall are genuine centres and therefore a better centre pairing than Lynne and Toupou. We haven’t had two genuinely high standard proper centres since Domic/Atkins/Demetriou so NO I haven’t had a “brain fart” I’m just better than you at judging players

Firstly, when we talk about centre partnerships, there is no relationship between centres apart from playing in the same team. It's good to have two good ones in the team but it's not a partnership and hasn't been a partnership since we moved away from inside and outside centres a long time ago.

Second, Tupou not being a centre seems a strange thing to say. He may not be a perfect passing centre like a Collis but not all centres are. Mal Meninga was pretty good at being a running centre. He could pass of course but he ran at defenders first, just like Tupou.
It's just a different style.