Re: Kelepi dropped : Fri Feb 18, 2022 3:12 pm  

Now there’s no reserve game it makes sense to keep Kelepi with the squad .. his mental health and confidence will be aided by being part of the group... even if he doesn’t play!

Unless there’s another reason he was ‘dropped’

Re: Kelepi dropped : Fri Feb 18, 2022 3:17 pm  

vastman wrote:

So he’s the only player to ever do that? Players make mistakes and wingers mistakes tend to be more obvious than most. It was a pee poor effort but that tends to be the reasons most tries get scored.

Most games would be nil nil draws were it not for defensive errors, very few tries are what you’d call pure.

One of our tries came from a glaring error from Hull, will they drop said player. You’re being hyper critical imo and if your lad progresses you’ll find that’s not always a good thing.

So its ok to drop one player for been poor but not another.if the only impact a player as on a game is for his own team to concede does he deserve to keep his place was he any better or worse than player dropped.its not about 1 mistake as you point out its about the whole game.for what its worth i dont know or care if kelepi is dropped or not its good to have a coach who is prepared to make these decisions rather than have faves as long as it applies to all players all season injuries permitted

[PopTart]

Re: Kelepi dropped : Fri Feb 18, 2022 3:32 pm  

Reserve grade game is off now anyway so he isn't playing.

Re: Kelepi dropped : Fri Feb 18, 2022 4:26 pm  

PopTart wrote:

The only evidence we have is that Willie says he's dropped. I'm prepared to believe that.
Saying I'm blinded by passion is a bit strange considering no one knows Kelepi's vax status.
I'm saying it doesn't matter to me either way. He's still dropped. But it seems it does matter to you to prove something you can't prove.
So I asked why it matters to you? Why not just believe what Willie says? It's not like you are whistleblowing some great conspiracy.

Neither of us know, that’s my point

He’s being dropped and that could mean anything

Why does it matter so much to you by the way?
Feels like that your trying to convince / force people to take your views act the facts

Yes he’s being dropped

Confidence or not vaxed
How can you prove love you are correct?

You can’t

Re: Kelepi dropped : Fri Feb 18, 2022 4:34 pm  

vastman wrote:

Rubbishing someone’s opinion states the poster who does it all the time. Your hypocrisy is quite breathtaking at times.

I would be stunned at your own hypocrisy however every other post of yours is aggressively disagreeing with people, so I’m not surprised to see you chip in here to try and rescue your cyber bird poptart at all

It’s probably the closest you’ll get to one

This forum is all you have in your life

I feel genuinely sorry for you

Re: Kelepi dropped : Fri Feb 18, 2022 4:35 pm  

Luppylad wrote:

So its ok to drop one player for been poor but not another.if the only impact a player as on a game is for his own team to concede does he deserve to keep his place was he any better or worse than player dropped.its not about 1 mistake as you point out its about the whole game.for what its worth i dont know or care if kelepi is dropped or not its good to have a coach who is prepared to make these decisions rather than have faves as long as it applies to all players all season injuries permitted

You're making a huge assumption here. You are assuming that WP thinks TL's form is poor but matey that's just your opinion and WP clearly sees it differently. I'll say again you don't drop a player on one mistake. The reasons KT has been dropped are possibly way more complex for reasons eluded to already. You are trying to second guess the coaching team which is a mistake IMO. I know you have connections with the club but you're not that far up the information food chain just yet, one day maybe .

People should just let it go IMO, WP has made his decision and after a start of the season narrow defeat, and a good end to last season, questioning it is way way too premature at this point IMHO.

Re: Kelepi dropped : Fri Feb 18, 2022 4:39 pm  

musson wrote:

I would be stunned at your own hypocrisy however every other post of yours is aggressively disagreeing with people, so I’m not surprised to see you chip in here to try and rescue your cyber bird poptart at all

It’s probably the closest you’ll get to one

This forum is all you have in your life

I feel genuinely sorry for you

Yeah yeah yeah and honestly I'm truly grateful for your concern, but I'm not the one who came out bagging someone for doing it, you are. Then true to form when challenged you immediately revert to throwing personal insults. Sadly you just don't see your own flaws and I don't suppose you ever will.

[PopTart]

Re: Kelepi dropped : Fri Feb 18, 2022 4:54 pm  

musson wrote:

Neither of us know, that’s my point

He’s being dropped and that could mean anything

Why does it matter so much to you by the way?
Feels like that your trying to convince / force people to take your views act the facts

Yes he’s being dropped

Confidence or not vaxed
How can you prove love you are correct?

You can’t

Are you following this thread. That is what I said to you and you said I was blinded.

The difference between out opinions is Willie Poaching said what I said. You have created your opinion from a strange belief that he's telling lies and hearsay about vax status of the team.

As I have said twice now. I don't care.

Re: Kelepi dropped : Fri Feb 18, 2022 5:14 pm  

vastman wrote:

You're making a huge assumption here. You are assuming that WP thinks TL's form is poor but matey that's just your opinion and WP clearly sees it differently. I'll say again you don't drop a player on one mistake. The reasons KT has been dropped are possibly way more complex for reasons eluded to already. You are trying to second guess the coaching team which is a mistake IMO. I know you have connections with the club but you're not that far up the information food chain just yet, one day maybe .

People should just let it go IMO, WP has made his decision and after a start of the season narrow defeat, and a good end to last season, questioning it is way way too premature at this point IMHO.

Thats the thing im not making any assumption i actually dont care weather KT is dropped or not playing for any other reason i actually likeus having a coach prepared to do things like this.and i also dont feel the club should inform fans why either.but i am entitled to an opinion and if kt is dropped i hope others get the same and yes tl was poor in my opinion.as for info food chain as you put it i dont pretend or want to be in any kind of chain i certainly dont pretend to know things only things i postvis how the lads been goingin college league which is cos i go and yes i knew mimms was due to play tonight.

All i really care about right now is come september we are not sitting 12th cos i believe once the stadium is moving and with the young talent we do have coming through the club will only get stronger

Re: Kelepi dropped : Fri Feb 18, 2022 7:26 pm  

jonh wrote:

If Kershaw is fit I’d have him start vs Catalans at the expense of Lineham definitely.

Been very unimpressed with Lineham so far.

The defensive effort for the Gale try was appalling and totally unacceptable.

If anyone was going to the reserves game tonight it has been cancelled FYI.

I'm fairly sure that the last we heard on Kershaw was that it was likely to be June/July before he would be fit to play again ??