Re: Wigan in cup : Tue Apr 05, 2022 4:27 pm  

Makes me laugh when refs are announced and you get the posts of oh we’ve no chance now so and so doesn’t like us etc…simple fact is it’s in our own hands…don’t feel sorry for ourselves if things go against us, just get on with it…they all make mistakes…was a shocking decision at Warrington just before half time that mattered not..some stuff went for us against Salford, some against…just be smart with it and don’t feel sorry for ourselves when for spells in games things go against us because they will..

Re: Wigan in cup : Tue Apr 05, 2022 4:36 pm  

upthecats wrote:

Makes me laugh when refs are announced and you get the posts of oh we’ve no chance now so and so doesn’t like us etc…simple fact is it’s in our own hands…don’t feel sorry for ourselves if things go against us, just get on with it…they all make mistakes…was a shocking decision at Warrington just before half time that mattered not..some stuff went for us against Salford, some against…just be smart with it and don’t feel sorry for ourselves when for spells in games things go against us because they will..

sq

Have to agree
Frustrating as it is at times the refs don't miss tackles, drop the ball or make bad tackles.
Our fate is in our hands not the referees.

[PopTart]

Re: Wigan in cup : Tue Apr 05, 2022 6:08 pm  

upthecats wrote:

Makes me laugh when refs are announced and you get the posts of oh we’ve no chance now so and so doesn’t like us etc…simple fact is it’s in our own hands…don’t feel sorry for ourselves if things go against us, just get on with it…they all make mistakes…was a shocking decision at Warrington just before half time that mattered not..some stuff went for us against Salford, some against…just be smart with it and don’t feel sorry for ourselves when for spells in games things go against us because they will..

I agree.
Apparently the ref against Warrington was categorically cheating against us.....but the ref who missed a forward pass against Salford was fine and just doing his job.

Re: Wigan in cup : Tue Apr 05, 2022 6:36 pm  

PopTart wrote:

'Give it some air' and 'off the cuff' do not go with 'error free play'

You have to accept errors if you want to push it but as long as your defense is ready you can do it.

When I say error free I mean silly mistakes , play the balls ,not finding touch , silly drop outs ,not taking the 2 on offer ,obviously slinging a few hail Mary’s will come at a cost , but when they stick boy does it look good

Re: Wigan in cup : Tue Apr 05, 2022 6:41 pm  

PopTart wrote:

I agree.
Apparently the ref against Warrington was categorically cheating against us.....but the ref who missed a forward pass against Salford was fine and just doing his job.

Bit extreme PT.

Missing forward passes is a regular and understandable problem, it’s just part of the game. Although I don’t think the ref cheated in a deliberate way, he did cheat the fans by being incompetent in the extreme.

It’s not that he missed the offence it’s the fact that he chose to make a snap decision on a clearly suspect play when he didn’t have to. There was simply no logical reason for not taking that one to the VR none whatsoever, it was pure incompetence with zero mitigating circumstances.

I’ll put it this way, it was a thousand times harder to get that one wrong yet he chose to do so, total idiocy.

Missing a forward pass is unfortunate but it’s just human error involving an instant decision in real time. There are no options for forward passes, there were plenty at Warrington.

[PopTart]

Re: Wigan in cup : Tue Apr 05, 2022 9:15 pm  

vastman wrote:

Bit extreme PT.

Missing forward passes is a regular and understandable problem, it’s just part of the game. Although I don’t think the ref cheated in a deliberate way, he did cheat the fans by being incompetent in the extreme.

It’s not that he missed the offence it’s the fact that he chose to make a snap decision on a clearly suspect play when he didn’t have to. There was simply no logical reason for not taking that one to the VR none whatsoever, it was pure incompetence with zero mitigating circumstances.

I’ll put it this way, it was a thousand times harder to get that one wrong yet he chose to do so, total idiocy.

Missing a forward pass is unfortunate but it’s just human error involving an instant decision in real time. There are no options for forward passes, there were plenty at Warrington.

But it's not cheating. It's a mistake. That's the only point I'm making.
You not understanding his decision does not mean he didn't make it with genuine intent.

The forward pass was far more damaging from a Salford point of view.

[PopTart]

Re: Wigan in cup : Tue Apr 05, 2022 9:18 pm  

Kettykat wrote:

When I say error free I mean silly mistakes , play the balls ,not finding touch , silly drop outs ,not taking the 2 on offer ,obviously slinging a few hail Mary’s will come at a cost , but when they stick boy does it look good

On that we most definitely agree.

Re: Wigan in cup : Tue Apr 05, 2022 9:34 pm  

PopTart wrote:

But it's not cheating. It's a mistake. That's the only point I'm making.
You not understanding his decision does not mean he didn't make it with genuine intent.

The forward pass was far more damaging from a Salford point of view.

To be fair having watched it again the pass from Miller to TJ is quite a way forward, unless Steve is drawing his lines at angles.

What’s worse from a Salford point of view is both the ref and touch judge are both in very good positions to see it, and maybe the touch judge on the other side of the field is/should be even better placed as having that distance should assist.

I won’t lose any sleep over it, as I said plenty have gone against us over the years.

When the video ref is there I think we probably do have the technology to judge on forward passes. If they can get these onside offside call right in football when their are literally mm in it then I’m sure we have enough cameras and the software to get them right. I’m sure they now call on them to judge them in Union.

On this occasion it went for us, but if the technology exists we need to use it to get it right when we can.

[PopTart]

Re: Wigan in cup : Tue Apr 05, 2022 9:59 pm  

jonh wrote:

To be fair having watched it again the pass from Miller to TJ is quite a way forward, unless Steve is drawing his lines at angles.

What’s worse from a Salford point of view is both the ref and touch judge are both in very good positions to see it, and maybe the touch judge on the other side of the field is/should be even better placed as having that distance should assist.

I won’t lose any sleep over it, as I said plenty have gone against us over the years.

When the video ref is there I think we probably do have the technology to judge on forward passes. If they can get these onside offside call right in football when their are literally mm in it then I’m sure we have enough cameras and the software to get them right. I’m sure they now call on them to judge them in Union.

On this occasion it went for us, but if the technology exists we need to use it to get it right when we can.

The problem is for rugby league is that they don't have video ref at every game so it's deemed unfair.

Re: Wigan in cup : Tue Apr 05, 2022 10:28 pm  

PopTart wrote:

But it's not cheating. It's a mistake. That's the only point I'm making.
You not understanding his decision does not mean he didn't make it with genuine intent.

The forward pass was far more damaging from a Salford point of view.

Just to be clear PT, the ref at Wire chose not to listen to his assistant and not to go to the VR to check whether Kelepi had been pulled back.
This is somewhat different to missing a forward pass.

Dont know if it was cheating but, it was poor refereeing at it's worst.

No try, no review and not even a bloody penalty.

Yes, we won the game and nobody can know what difference going in all square at ht would have made to the final score but, it was an absolute shocker.

I presume that you weren't at the game ?