Re: 19 V Widnes : Mon Jun 25, 2018 2:12 pm  

chissitt wrote:

aye I'm sure the Chapelwho brothers should do okay in the championship next season, that is if they learn't anything from the mullering our props gave them yesterday.

It would be a massive waste of talent for them to play in the Championship, as much as it would pain me for them to leave this club I cannot see a situation where a Super league team would not come in for them should the unlikely happen and we were playing Championship next season! Saying that I would imagine NRL clubs to be sniffing around them in the coming seasons so we are likely to lose them anyway.

Re: 19 V Widnes : Mon Jun 25, 2018 2:14 pm  

When are the brothers signing for Warrington?

Re: 19 V Widnes : Mon Jun 25, 2018 2:18 pm  

ScouseViking wrote:

Your pack struggled to handle Ted and Jay alike whilst they were on the field of play.

A quick check on `average gain` will, I am sure show they out-performed your established `big name` props throughout the game?

Average gains

Jay 8.67
Ted 9.13
Pauli 11.56

I like both your boys. But they wouldn’t get near our first choice pack

Re: 19 V Widnes : Mon Jun 25, 2018 2:25 pm  

Daddycool wrote:

Average gains

Jay 8.67
Ted 9.13
Pauli 11.56

I like both your boys. But they wouldn’t get near our first choice pack

Did Pauli not play in the second row? Also why have you not mentioned Fifita, Hirst or England? Surely not anything to do with the fact England`s average gain was 6 meters?

Look I am not trying to say your pack is rubbish, I am merely defending my own comments on the Brothers who have been the silver lining in a very dark and dingy season....

P.S. if you get offered the Chapelhow brothers, I would take them in a heartbeat, although I am sure you will be competing against more or less every club in the league for there signature.

Re: 19 V Widnes : Mon Jun 25, 2018 2:26 pm  

Daddycool wrote:

Average gains

Jay 8.67
Ted 9.13
Pauli 11.56

I like both your boys. But they wouldn’t get near our first choice pack

I disagree on that by the way, both are better than England, Huby and Hirst.. Ted is around on par with Fifita.

Re: 19 V Widnes : Mon Jun 25, 2018 2:28 pm  

ScouseViking wrote:

Did Pauli not play in the second row? Also why have you not mentioned Fifita, Hirst or England? Surely not anything to do with the fact England`s average gain was 6 meters?

Look I am not trying to say your pack is rubbish, I am merely defending my own comments on the Brothers who have been the silver lining in a very dark and dingy season....

P.S. if you get offered the Chapelhow brothers, I would take them in a heartbeat, although I am sure you will be competing against more or less every club in the league for there signature.

We’ve been offerred them 3 times in the past 18 months.

In fairness to both of them, I don’t think they want to leave home/northwest

Re: 19 V Widnes : Mon Jun 25, 2018 2:33 pm  

ScouseViking wrote:

Placing the final result aside for a short moment, in the view of someone who watches Widnes most weeks that is the first time this season we have really dominated a team as we did so often in patches in that second half.

It really is a concern for Trinity spectators going forward as to just how you are to compete in your final 5 games and for that reason I really cannot see you `Getting of the hook` and escaping the greatly feared Middle eights!

Good from our perspective as I would much rather play Wakefield than Catalan as it stands, I think playing that game again and seeing just how easy you can be broken down the result would be far from the outcome it was on the weekend.

I think you need to buy a new dictionary - the definition of dominated in mine is very different to what I saw from Widnes yesterday.

Re: 19 V Widnes : Mon Jun 25, 2018 2:42 pm  

ScouseViking wrote:

Did Pauli not play in the second row? Also why have you not mentioned Fifita, Hirst or England? Surely not anything to do with the fact England`s average gain was 6 meters?

Look I am not trying to say your pack is rubbish, I am merely defending my own comments on the Brothers who have been the silver lining in a very dark and dingy season....

P.S. if you get offered the Chapelhow brothers, I would take them in a heartbeat, although I am sure you will be competing against more or less every club in the league for there signature.

Jay - 9 carries - 78 metres - Average 8.67 - Clean breaks 0 - Tackle busts 0
Ted - 8 Carries - 73 metres - Average 9.13 - Clean breaks 0 - Tackle busts 0

Fifita - 11 carries - 90 metres - Average 8.18 - Clean breaks 1 - Tackle busts 4
England - 10 carries - 60 metres - Average 6.00 - Clean breaks 0 - Tackle busts 2
Hirst - 10 carries - 64 metres - Average 6.4 - Clean breaks 0 - Tackle busts 2

Pauli - 9 carries - 104 metres - Average 11.56 - Clean breaks 0 - Tackle busts 5
Arona - 16 carries - 110 metres - Average 6.88 - Clean breaks 1 - Tackle busts 3

Your brothers did OK, but to suggest that they offer more than our pack is ridiculous IMO

Re: 19 V Widnes : Mon Jun 25, 2018 2:48 pm  

Not one SL club would go in for the Chaplewho brothers, to say otherwise in borderline insanity.

Re: 19 V Widnes : Mon Jun 25, 2018 3:06 pm  

Something he’s not yet mentioned is Tom Johnstone rather brilliant try. This is the same Tom who he’d rather have Ourvan over yet the apparantly out of form Tom beat half their team - when did Ourvan ever do thatcertanly not in a Widnes shirt